Blog

Ai-jen Poo and the Domestic Workers Left Out of the New Deal

Why nannies, housekeepers and home care workers were written out of 1930s labor law, and how Ai-jen Poo and domestic workers won New York's 2010 bill of rights, the first of its kind.

Some of the most important labor organizing of the past quarter century happened in playgrounds. In New York City around the turn of the century, organizers would go to parks on weekday mornings, when the people pushing strollers and watching toddlers on the swings were, in many neighborhoods, not the children's parents. They were nannies, many of them immigrant women from the Caribbean, Latin America, the Philippines, Tibet, Nepal and Africa. They worked alone, in separate homes, for separate employers, with no coworkers, no break room and no union hall. Labor law barely knew they existed. One of the organizers who went looking for them was a young Taiwanese American woman named Ai-jen Poo. A decade later, she and the women she met in those parks would get New York to pass a law that no state had ever passed, and the story of why they had to begin with the 1930s.

In short: When Congress wrote the core New Deal labor laws in the 1930s, it left out domestic workers and farmworkers, jobs held disproportionately by Black workers in the South. Domestic workers spent decades fighting their way back in. Ai-jen Poo, an organizer with Domestic Workers United and later the National Domestic Workers Alliance, helped win New York's Domestic Workers' Bill of Rights in 2010, the first such state law, and a string of states followed.

The workers the New Deal skipped

The New Deal is remembered as the moment American workers got a floor. The National Labor Relations Act of 1935 gave workers the right to organize unions and bargain. The Social Security Act of the same year created old-age insurance and unemployment insurance. The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 set a minimum wage, overtime and child labor rules.

Each of those laws, as originally written, left out two large groups: agricultural workers and domestic workers, the cooks, maids, nannies and laundresses who worked in private homes. In the 1930s, those two categories included a large share of all Black workers in the country, and in the South a large share of Black women who worked for wages did domestic work.

Why were they excluded? Historians have argued about this for decades, and the honest answer is that more than one force was at work.

One account emphasizes race and politics. President Roosevelt needed the votes of Southern Democrats, who held powerful committee chairmanships, to pass his program. Many of those legislators were determined to protect the region's low-wage, racially segregated labor system, and excluding the jobs held by most Black workers in the South was a way to do it without writing race into the law.

Another account emphasizes administration. Officials at the time argued that collecting payroll taxes from millions of individual households and small farms would be hard for a new agency, and some reformers thought it better to start with industrial workers and expand later. Some historians who make this case note that a number of countries excluded domestic workers from early social insurance for similar reasons.

These accounts are not mutually exclusive. What is not in dispute is the effect: for decades, the people who cooked, cleaned and cared for American families, disproportionately Black women and later immigrant women, had fewer legal protections than the people who worked in factories.

A slow climb back in

The exclusions eroded over time, piece by piece.

Social Security amendments in 1950 began covering domestic workers, with conditions. In 1974, Congress amended the Fair Labor Standards Act to extend minimum wage to most domestic workers, an expansion that civil rights and women's groups had pushed for. But the 1974 law kept out two groups: live-in domestic workers did not get overtime, and workers who provided companionship services to elderly and disabled people were exempt from minimum wage and overtime alike. Over the following decades, that companionship exemption came to cover a growing army of home care aides, many of them employed by agencies, not families.

The National Labor Relations Act exclusion has never been lifted. Domestic workers still have no federal right to organize and bargain collectively. Because they work for separate employers, that right might not do much for them even if they had it; there is no single boss to bargain with. That fact shaped everything about how domestic workers would organize.

Organizing people who work alone

Ai-jen Poo grew up largely in Pittsburgh, the daughter of immigrants from Taiwan. In New York in the late 1990s, she organized with a women workers' project at an Asian American community organization, and in 2000 she helped found Domestic Workers United, a New York organization of nannies, housekeepers and elder caregivers.

The organizing required inventing methods. The playgrounds and parks were one place. Churches, subway platforms, the commuter buses that carried workers to suburban homes, and ethnic neighborhood associations were others. Organizers collected stories: workers who had been paid a few dollars an hour, workers whose passports were held by employers, workers who had gone years without a day off, workers who were sexually harassed or assaulted and had nowhere to turn.

Domestic Workers United ran campaigns against individual abusive employers, sometimes with pickets outside apartment buildings. But Poo and the workers concluded early that individual campaigns could never reach the hundreds of thousands of domestic workers in New York. They needed a law.

The bill of rights

The campaign for a New York Domestic Workers' Bill of Rights ran for years. Workers went to Albany in buses, many of them for the first time, to visit legislators. They brought employers who supported the bill, which mattered: some of the most effective testimony came from parents who employed nannies and wanted clear rules. Allies included labor unions, faith groups and organizations of employers who saw the bill as a way to do the right thing without guessing what the right thing was.

The opposition was not loud, but it was real. Some legislators worried that new mandates would burden middle-class families, push employment off the books and be impossible to enforce in private homes. Some business groups worried about expanding the reach of labor law into households.

In 2010, the Legislature passed the bill, and Governor David Paterson signed it that summer. It took effect later that year. Among its provisions:

  • domestic workers were covered by the state's minimum wage and overtime rules, with overtime for live-in workers kicking in at a higher weekly threshold than for other workers;
  • a guaranteed day of rest each week, with overtime pay if a worker agreed to work it;
  • three paid days off a year after one year with the same employer;
  • protection under the state's human rights law against sexual harassment and harassment based on race, religion, national origin and other characteristics.

Some of what workers wanted was left out, including paid sick days and advance notice before termination, and the bill did not give domestic workers collective bargaining rights. Lawmakers instead asked the state labor department to study the feasibility of bargaining. It was, by any measure, a compromise. It was also the first law of its kind in the country.

The spread

What happened next showed the power of a first law. Domestic worker groups in other states, now linked through the National Domestic Workers Alliance, which Poo had helped found in 2007 and went on to lead, ran their own campaigns.

Hawaii passed a domestic workers' bill of rights in 2013. California passed one the same year, extending overtime to many domestic workers, which advocates had sought for years after an earlier version was vetoed. Massachusetts passed a law in 2014 that included written agreements, notice before termination for live-in workers and protections for workers' privacy. More states and cities, including some that are not usually thought of as progressive strongholds, have followed in the years since.

At the federal level, the Obama Labor Department finalized a rule in 2013, which took effect in 2015, narrowing the companionship exemption so that home care aides employed by agencies were covered by minimum wage and overtime. A court challenge by industry groups failed. That rule mattered for well over a million workers, many of them women of color, who do some of the hardest physical and emotional work in the economy.

In 2019, Senator Kamala Harris and Representative Pramila Jayapal introduced a National Domestic Workers Bill of Rights in Congress. It did not pass.

Internationally, the International Labour Organization adopted a convention on decent work for domestic workers in 2011, which domestic workers' organizations from many countries, including the United States, had helped shape.

Employers as allies

One feature of the domestic workers' movement set it apart from many labor campaigns: it recruited the bosses.

Most people who employ a nanny or a home caregiver are not corporations. They are families, often busy and sometimes stretched, who have never thought of themselves as employers and do not know the rules. Organizers realized that many of them wanted to do right by the person caring for their children or parents, but had no guide.

Out of that insight came Hand in Hand, a national network of employers of domestic workers, founded around the time of the New York victory. It gives families tools such as model work agreements, guidance on pay and time off, and advice on paying payroll taxes. It also brings employers to legislative hearings, where a parent explaining why clear rules help her family can be more persuasive than any advocate.

That approach reflects something the domestic workers' movement understood early. The relationship between a family and the person who cares for its children or elders is unusually intimate. Treating it as a fight between enemies would have been both inaccurate and self-defeating. Treating it as a relationship that both sides want to be fair made allies of people who might otherwise have been opponents.

The case against, taken seriously

It is fair to ask whether laws like these work, and some of the skepticism deserves a hearing.

Enforcement inside private homes is genuinely hard. Labor inspectors cannot drop into households the way they visit factories, and many workers fear losing their jobs, or worse, if they complain. Advocates themselves have said that years after the law passed, many workers and employers still did not know what it required. Some economists worry that higher costs push families toward informal, off-the-books arrangements, leaving workers with less protection than before.

The answers are partial but real. Education campaigns aimed at employers, many of whom want to comply but do not know how, have helped. Model contracts and simple payroll services make compliance easier for families. Some cities have created offices that handle domestic workers' complaints. And the alternative, no law at all, guarantees workers have no rights to claim. A law that is hard to enforce in every case still sets a standard that a worker can point to, that an honest employer can follow, and that a court can apply when something goes badly wrong.

Care as the economy's foundation

Poo's later work has moved from domestic work to the broader care economy: child care, elder care and the workers who provide both. In 2011 she helped found Caring Across Generations, a campaign linking care workers with the families who rely on them. She received a MacArthur Fellowship in 2014 and wrote a book, The Age of Dignity, about the coming wave of aging Americans and who will care for them.

Her core argument, which you can agree or disagree with, is that care work is not a side issue. As the population ages, the number of Americans who need help bathing, dressing and eating will grow, and the people who provide that help are among the lowest paid in the economy. Families are caught in the middle, paying more than they can afford while the workers they pay earn too little to live on. The fix, in this view, has to include public investment, through programs like Medicaid's home care services, so that neither families nor workers bear the whole cost.

That argument crosses party lines more than you might think. Rural counties, where populations are older and home care workers are scarce, feel the shortage keenly. Veterans' families feel it. Adult children in every state, juggling work and a parent's care, feel it.

The women in the New York parks were, in a sense, the first to make the case. They were raising other people's children and caring for other people's parents while their own families made do. Their demand was simple: that the law see them. In 2010, New York's did.

What you can do

  1. Learn your state's rules. Whether you employ a nanny or caregiver or work as one, start with your state's wage floor. The state minimum wage list shows every state's rate, and your state labor department explains any domestic worker protections.
  2. Find the organizers. Domestic worker groups, immigrant rights organizations and legal aid clinics are listed by state and cause on the organizations directory. Many offer know-your-rights trainings and model contracts for families.
  3. Ask for a state bill of rights. If your state has not passed one, contact your state legislators through the representatives lookup and ask whether they would sponsor one.
  4. Follow the bigger fights. Our racial justice topic page traces the history of exclusions like these, and our immigration topic page follows the policies that shape who does care work.

The New Deal drew a line around the workers it would protect. Domestic workers have spent nearly a century moving that line, one law at a time, and they did most of it starting from a park bench.

Latest on this topic