Blog

Bears Ears, Shrunk by 85 Percent in 2017 and Restored in 2021

Five tribes that had disagreed for generations proposed protecting Bears Ears together. Here is how the Utah monument was created, cut, restored and what still threatens it.

In the summer of 2015, leaders of five tribal nations sat down together to draw a map. That alone was unusual. The Hopi Tribe, the Navajo Nation, the Ute Mountain Ute Tribe, the Ute Indian Tribe of the Uintah and Ouray Reservation and the Pueblo of Zuni do not share a single history; some of them had argued in court with one another over land for most of a century. But they shared a place in southeastern Utah, a high country of red-rock canyons, juniper mesas and cliff houses, watched over by two matching buttes that the Diné call Shash Jáa', the bear's ears. Their ancestors had lived there, hunted there, buried their dead there and gathered medicine there for thousands of years. And they had watched looters dig up graves in its canyons for as long as anyone could remember. The coalition they formed asked the federal government for something no tribal alliance had quite asked for before: not just protection, but a real role in managing the land once it was protected.

In short: Bears Ears National Monument began as a joint proposal from five tribes and was created by Barack Obama in December 2016. Donald Trump cut it by about 85 percent a year later; Joe Biden restored it in October 2021. The tribes' co-management role is the part worth defending most, and it still depends on who holds power.

What the coalition asked for

The Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition did not appear from nowhere. For years before 2015, Navajo community members in San Juan County, Utah, had been documenting the region's sacred and cultural sites, interviewing elders about where plants were gathered and where ceremonies happened. A grassroots group called Utah Diné Bikéyah grew out of that work. Their maps showed something outsiders tended to miss: this was not empty wilderness. It was a lived-in, prayed-over landscape, scattered with an enormous number of archaeological sites, many of them unexcavated and unprotected.

The coalition proposed a monument of about 1.9 million acres. It asked that tribes share management with federal agencies, so that the people who knew the land best would help decide how it was cared for. That second request mattered as much as the first. Federal land agencies had managed the area for decades, and grave robbing had continued anyway. Raids by federal agents in 2009 on artifact traffickers in nearby Blanding made national news and showed how deep the trade ran.

December 2016: a monument, and a commission

On December 28, 2016, in the last weeks of his presidency, Barack Obama proclaimed Bears Ears National Monument at about 1.35 million acres. It was smaller than the coalition had asked for, and some areas the tribes cared about were left out. But the proclamation did something new. It created a Bears Ears Commission made up of one elected officer from each of the five tribes, to bring tribal knowledge into the management of the monument alongside the Bureau of Land Management and the Forest Service.

Utah's governor, its congressional delegation and many local officials were furious. They saw a federal takeover of land that ranchers had grazed and that some hoped to open further to oil, gas and uranium. Some residents of San Juan County, including some Navajo residents who valued access for firewood and grazing, also had doubts. The opposition was not invented; it reflected a long, bitter history in rural Utah of decisions made in Washington.

December 2017: the cut

In April 2017, President Trump signed an executive order directing Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke to review national monuments created since 1996 that covered more than 100,000 acres. Bears Ears was the obvious target. On December 4, 2017, at the state capitol in Salt Lake City, Trump signed proclamations shrinking Bears Ears by about 85 percent, to roughly 200,000 acres split into two separate units, and cutting Grand Staircase-Escalante by about half.

The cuts were the largest reduction of protected land in American history. The lands removed included places the tribes considered among the most important. Reporting afterward by The Washington Post found that a uranium company with a mill near the monument had urged the Interior Department to shrink its boundaries. That mill, the White Mesa Mill, sits close to the White Mesa community of the Ute Mountain Ute Tribe, whose members have spent years raising concerns about it.

The tribes sued within days. So did conservation groups, scientists and outdoor businesses. Their argument was simple: the Antiquities Act lets a president create a monument, and says nothing about letting a president shrink one. Only Congress, which has the constitutional power over federal land, could do that. The government argued the opposite. The courts never reached an answer before the political winds turned.

What is out there

It helps to know what the fight is over. Bears Ears is a landscape of mesas and deep canyons, from the high forest around the two buttes down to the sandstone of Cedar Mesa and the long fin of Comb Ridge. Tucked into alcoves and canyon walls are the stone and mud houses, granaries and kivas of Ancestral Puebloan people, along with rock art panels that span many centuries and older traces left by people who hunted and gathered there long before. Many sites have never been formally recorded. Some are still used by tribal members for prayer and gathering plants.

The area also draws a very different crowd. Indian Creek, in the northern part of the monument, is one of the best-known crack climbing areas in the world, and climbers, hikers, river runners and backpackers have long come to the region. That gave the monument a second set of defenders when it was cut.

The outdoor industry took a public side in 2017. The Outdoor Retailer trade show, which had been held in Salt Lake City for years, announced it would leave Utah, after the state's leaders pushed for the Bears Ears reduction and for transferring federal land to the state. The outdoor clothing company Patagonia replaced its home page with a black screen declaring that the president had stolen your land, and joined the lawsuits. It was an unusual moment in which a business sector put money behind a land fight led by tribes.

None of that would have mattered without the tribes, who had made the argument for years before any company joined in. But it showed that the coalition behind the monument ran wider than critics claimed.

A county that changed its mind

There is a quieter story inside the Bears Ears fight that shows how much depends on who gets to vote.

About half the people of San Juan County are Native American, most of them Navajo, a share far higher than anywhere else in Utah. For decades the three-member county commission had been elected from districts that the Navajo Nation and Navajo voters argued in federal court were drawn to dilute their votes. In 2017 a federal judge agreed, and new districts were drawn. In the 2018 election, Navajo candidates won a majority on the commission for the first time. The new majority reversed the county's official position and supported the full monument.

Hold that sequence in mind: the same land, the same people, a different map of districts, and a different answer about what the county wanted. When state leaders said "the people of San Juan County" opposed Bears Ears, the question was always which people they meant. Fair districts did not settle the argument, but they changed who was in the room.

October 2021: the restoration

On October 8, 2021, President Biden restored Bears Ears to about 1.36 million acres, adding back the land Trump had removed and keeping a small parcel Trump had added. He restored Grand Staircase-Escalante the same day. The announcement was made alongside Deb Haaland, a citizen of the Pueblo of Laguna and the first Native American to serve as a Cabinet secretary, who had backed the monument as a member of Congress.

The restoration also revived the Bears Ears Commission. In 2022 the five tribes and the two federal agencies signed a cooperative agreement setting out how they would manage the monument together. The agencies then spent years writing a management plan that drew on tribal knowledge, including how to protect cultural sites, how to handle growing tourism, and how to keep traditional uses like gathering plants and firewood.

Utah sued to undo the restoration, arguing the monument was far larger than the "smallest area compatible" with protecting its objects. A federal judge dismissed the suit in 2024, and the state appealed. The question of whether a president can shrink a monument, and how large one may be, was left for another day. For the current status of land cases in the federal courts, the court tracker follows the Supreme Court's term and the emergency docket.

The other side's best argument

The fairest version of the opposition goes like this. Rural San Juan County is poor. Its residents, Native and non-Native, have depended on grazing, energy work and access to public land for generations. A monument of more than a million acres changes the rules for all of that, and those changes were made by a president, not by a vote of Congress or the people who live there. Tourists drawn by the monument bring traffic, trash and damage to fragile sites. Supporters of the cuts said they were returning decisions to local people.

That case has real weight, and anyone who supports Bears Ears should take it seriously. Most traditional uses, including grazing permits, continued under the monument, and the management plan was supposed to protect them. Tourism pressure is real; it is one reason the tribes wanted a role in planning, since they know which sites are too fragile for crowds. But the deeper answer is about who counts as local. The tribes who proposed the monument are local in the oldest sense of the word. Their nations border the land; their members live in San Juan County; their ancestors are buried in its canyons. A description of the dispute as Washington against rural Utah leaves out the rural Utahns who asked for the monument in the first place.

Why it is still not settled

Bears Ears has been protected, cut and restored in five years. That is the core problem. A landscape that people have used for thousands of years is being managed on a four-year cycle. Every presidential election becomes a referendum on whether the tribes' hard-won role will survive.

The way out of that cycle runs through Congress. Lawmakers could write the monument's boundaries and the tribes' co-management role into federal law, which no future proclamation could undo. Bills to do that have been introduced in past sessions without passing. Members of Congress from Utah have pushed the other way, for legislation that would shrink the monument or limit the president's monument power in the state. Neither side has had the votes. With Democrats winning both chambers on November 3, 2026, supporters may see a new opening when the next Congress is sworn in in January 2027, though any bill would still need the president's signature or enough votes to override a veto.

Meanwhile, the monument's future depends on management decisions made far from the headlines: how many visitors a canyon can handle, whether a road gets paved, whether a cultural site is marked on a map or left unmarked to protect it. Those decisions shape whether the monument works in practice. For more on how fights like this connect to land, race and power, see the racial justice topic page.

What you can do

The tribes spent years building the case for Bears Ears before anyone in Washington paid attention. Support for them works best when it is just as patient.

  1. Visit with care, or decide not to. If you go, stay on marked trails, never touch or move artifacts, keep off walls and roofs of structures, and learn which sites are closed. Some people who love the place have decided the kindest thing is to visit somewhere less fragile.
  2. Ask your members of Congress where they stand. The representatives finder shows your House member and senators, how to reach them, and their latest votes. Ask whether they would back legislation that writes the boundaries and the tribal role into law.
  3. Comment when management decisions open up. Agencies take public comment on plans for monuments and the lands around them, and on mining and drilling leases nearby. The list of rules open for comment shows what is open now and how to write a comment that agencies have to consider.
  4. Support tribe-led conservation. Native-led groups doing land, language and cultural work can be found through the directory of nonprofits by cause; look for environment and civil rights groups in Utah and the Four Corners.
  5. Follow fair-district fights where you live. San Juan County shows how the way district lines are drawn can decide whose voice a county speaks with. Register, vote, and learn how district maps get made in your own county and state.

The five nations that drew a map together in 2015 were told many times that their idea could not happen. It happened, then it was undone, then it happened again. Each time, the people who were still there afterward were the tribes. That patience is the strongest argument for giving them the last word on a place they never left.

Latest on this topic