Blog

Berkeley's Gas Ban, the Ninth Circuit and the Fight Over Stoves

How a one-page Berkeley ordinance on gas hookups ran into a 1975 appliance law, lost in the Ninth Circuit, and turned the kitchen stove into a culture-war object.

In July 2019 the Berkeley City Council voted, unanimously and without much drama, to stop running natural gas pipes into most new buildings starting in 2020. It was a modest rule on paper. It did not touch a single existing stove, furnace or water heater. Nobody had to rip anything out. But Berkeley was the first city in the country to do it, and within a couple of years dozens of California cities had followed, and then the ordinance landed in front of a federal appeals court that read a 1975 law about refrigerator labels and dishwasher efficiency and concluded that Berkeley had no power to do what it did. Somewhere along the way the humble gas range became a symbol of freedom for one side and a source of indoor pollution for the other. The case is a good way to see how climate policy actually gets made and unmade, and why the way you write a rule can matter as much as the goal.

In short: Berkeley's 2019 ban on gas hookups in new buildings was struck down in 2023 by a Ninth Circuit panel that held a federal appliance-efficiency law preempts it. The fight left real questions about health, cost and choice, and progressives now have better tools for cleaner buildings than a hookup ban.

A small ordinance with a big first

Berkeley's ordinance was short. New buildings, with some exceptions, could not be connected to the city's natural gas infrastructure. The reasoning in the city's findings was straightforward: buildings are a large source of greenhouse gas emissions in California, gas appliances burn a fossil fuel indoors, and it is cheaper to build a house all-electric from the start than to retrofit it later.

That last point was the heart of the strategy. Electrifying an existing home means replacing equipment that still works, and sometimes upgrading wiring and panels. Building it electric from day one avoids those costs. Climate advocates saw new construction as the easy part of a very hard problem.

The California Restaurant Association disagreed. Restaurants rely on gas ranges and woks for high-heat cooking, and the group sued in federal court in late 2019, arguing among other things that federal law preempted the city's rule. The district court dismissed the federal claim. Berkeley appeared to have won the first round.

What a 1975 appliance law has to do with your stove

The law at issue is the Energy Policy and Conservation Act, passed in 1975 after the oil shocks. Among many other things, it set up national efficiency standards for appliances such as furnaces, water heaters and kitchen equipment. To avoid a patchwork of fifty different appliance rules, Congress included a preemption clause: once a federal standard exists, states and localities cannot adopt their own regulations "concerning the energy efficiency" or "energy use" of covered products, with some exceptions such as certain building codes.

Read narrowly, that clause stops a city from saying a furnace must be more efficient than the federal standard. Berkeley's position was that it had not regulated any appliance at all. It had regulated pipes in the street. You can buy whatever stove you want; the city just won't connect it to gas.

In April 2023 a three-judge Ninth Circuit panel rejected that reading. The majority, in an opinion by Judge Patrick Bumatay, said the statute is about the energy use of appliances "at the point of use," and a rule that makes gas appliances useless in new buildings regulates their energy use just as surely as a rule banning the appliances outright. A city cannot, in the court's view, do indirectly what it is forbidden to do directly. The court later issued an amended opinion and declined to rehear the case with a larger panel, over a dissent from several judges who thought the panel had stretched the statute well beyond what Congress wrote.

Berkeley then moved to pause enforcement of its ordinance, and other cities with similar rules started reworking them.

The health argument, stated carefully

Supporters of building electrification point to two kinds of harm from gas appliances.

The first is climate. Burning gas releases carbon dioxide, and the gas system leaks methane, a far more potent short-term warming gas, at wells, pipelines and inside homes. A 2022 study by Stanford researchers measured methane leaking from stoves in dozens of homes and found that most of it escaped while the stoves were off, from fittings and connections.

The second is indoor air. Gas burners produce nitrogen dioxide and other pollutants. Nitrogen dioxide is linked to respiratory problems, and the link between gas cooking and childhood asthma has been studied for decades. A widely cited 2022 analysis estimated that about one in eight cases of childhood asthma in the United States could be attributed to gas stove use. The industry has contested that estimate, noting that it pooled earlier studies rather than measuring new cases, and the honest summary is that the evidence on nitrogen dioxide is strong while the exact size of the stove effect is debated. Ventilation helps a great deal: a range hood that vents outdoors, used every time you cook, cuts exposure.

None of that requires anyone to panic about the stove they already own. It does make a reasonable case for building new homes without gas.

How the stove became a flag

In January 2023 a commissioner at the Consumer Product Safety Commission told a reporter that a ban on new gas stoves was possible as the agency looked at indoor pollution. The reaction was immediate and enormous. Members of Congress posted videos defending their ranges. The commission's chair said the agency was not planning a ban, and the House later passed bills aimed at blocking one.

By then many states had already gone the other way. The gas industry and its allies had pushed laws in roughly two dozen states that forbid cities from restricting gas hookups. Texas, Florida, Ohio and others have such laws. A local climate idea had become a state-level preemption fight and then a national identity marker.

It is worth sitting with how strange that is. The kitchen range is, for most households, a modest share of home energy use; space and water heating use far more. But the stove is visible, personal and tied to cooking traditions. It made a perfect symbol, and symbols are easier to fight over than water heater efficiency ratings.

The other side's case, at full strength

Opponents of hookup bans make several arguments that deserve a straight answer.

Choice. People should be able to choose how they cook and heat. Many cooks prefer gas flames. Restaurants depend on them.

Cost. In some regions, gas heating is cheaper to run than electric resistance heat, and new all-electric construction can raise costs if builders are not used to it. Utilities need to build more electric capacity.

Reliability. Gas appliances can work during some power outages; electric ones cannot without backup. After grid failures like the one in Texas in February 2021, that argument has real weight, though gas systems also failed in that storm.

Who decides. Federal appliance policy was meant to be uniform. Letting each city set its own rules creates confusion for manufacturers and builders.

Here is the answer, as we see it. On choice, a building code always limits choice; that is what codes do, from wiring to stairs. The question is whether the limit is reasonable, and for new construction it often is. On cost, modern heat pumps have changed the math in most climates, and building electric avoids the cost of running gas lines in the first place; but where it does cost more, policy should say so and help. On reliability, the answer is a stronger grid and backup batteries, not a second fossil fuel network. On who decides, the Ninth Circuit has spoken for its region, and that is a fair point about legal design: if Congress meant to forbid local hookup rules, it could have said so plainly, and if it did not, Congress can clarify.

Progressives should also own a mistake. Leading with "bans" handed opponents a frame about taking things away. Many people who would happily buy an induction range heard "they're coming for your stove." That was never the policy, but it was the story.

Better tools than a ban

Cities and states did not stop after the ruling; they changed approach. Here are the main paths now in use.

Building performance and emissions standards. Instead of naming a fuel, codes can set limits on emissions or energy use per square foot, which builders can meet any way they like. Whether these survive preemption challenges depends on how they are written and on which court hears them.

Incentives and rebates. Paying people to choose heat pumps and induction cooktops avoids preemption problems entirely. The 2022 climate law created state-run rebates for electrification appliances.

Utility rules. State utility commissions can stop requiring other customers to subsidize new gas line extensions, which removes a hidden incentive to build with gas.

State law. New York passed a law in 2023 phasing out fossil fuel equipment in most new buildings, and it has faced its own lawsuits and delays. Other states are watching to see how those cases go.

Clean air standards for appliances. Some regional air districts in California have adopted rules on nitrogen oxide emissions from furnaces and water heaters, which effectively favour electric models over time.

The underlying goal, cleaner buildings and healthier indoor air, is still widely shared. The tools just need to be built to survive.

What the appliance on the counter actually is now

Part of the fight assumed the choice was between a gas flame and the coil-top electric range many people grew up with, the kind that took forever to heat and forever to cool. That is no longer the real comparison. Induction cooktops use a magnetic field to heat the pan itself rather than the surface beneath it. They boil water quickly, respond to the dial almost as fast as gas, and leave the cooktop cool enough to wipe while dinner simmers. Professional kitchens and cooking schools have adopted them in growing numbers.

Induction has drawbacks, and an honest account names them. The ranges have historically cost more than comparable gas or standard electric models, though prices have been falling. They need cookware that a magnet sticks to, so some aluminium and copper pans will not work. Older kitchens may need a new circuit. And woks, which rely on a tall flame licking up curved sides, are a genuine challenge; induction woks exist, but cooks who have spent decades over a gas burner are entitled to be skeptical.

Countertop induction burners, which plug into an ordinary outlet, have become a low-cost way for renters and the curious to try the technology without replacing anything. Some city and utility programs have lent them out, the way a library lends books, so households can test before they buy. That kind of small, practical step does more to change minds than any ordinance.

The gas system's slow arithmetic

There is a quieter economic story underneath the stove fight. Gas utilities recover the cost of their pipes from customers over decades. If fewer new buildings connect, and some existing customers leave for heat pumps, the people still on the system carry a larger share of those fixed costs. That could mean rising gas bills for the households least able to switch: renters, older homeowners on fixed incomes, families in older housing.

Regulators in several states have opened proceedings on how to plan for that, including whether utilities should keep extending and replacing pipe that may be used for fewer years than the accounting assumes. Advocates call this "managed transition," and it may matter more in the long run than any single city's hookup rule. Planning ahead lets regulators retire pipe gradually and target help to the customers who would otherwise be left holding the bill.

People in the kitchen

Think about who lives with these choices. A renter in an older apartment with a gas stove and no range hood cannot rip anything out; what she needs is ventilation and a landlord who will replace a broken appliance with an efficient one. A rural family on propane may be paying a lot for heat and could save with a heat pump, if someone helps with the up-front cost. A restaurant owner with a narrow margin needs a transition plan, not a lecture. A building trades worker wants to know that electrification means jobs.

When the policy speaks to them, it wins. When it sounds like a rule about other people's kitchens, it loses, even in a city as liberal as Berkeley.

What you can do

  • If you are replacing a stove anyway, look at induction. It heats fast, does not burn fuel indoors and is easy to clean. Whatever you cook on, use a range hood that vents outside.
  • Learn what your state and city allow. Many states have passed laws preempting local gas rules; others encourage electrification. The climate policy page follows those fights, and the courts page follows the litigation.
  • Watch federal appliance rules. Department of Energy efficiency standards for stoves, furnaces and water heaters go through public comment; when one is open you will find it on the comment page, sorted by closing date, with tips on writing a useful comment.
  • Check your local power mix. The case for electrification gets stronger as the grid gets cleaner; the climate data page shows clean power by state.
  • Talk to your state legislators about rebates and gas line subsidies; their contact details are on the representatives page.

Latest on this topic