Blog
Bismarck's 1883 Sickness Insurance and the Multi-Payer Path to Universal Care
A conservative chancellor's 1883 law started the oldest national health insurance system. Here is how Germany and the Netherlands cover everyone without a single payer.
The first national health insurance law in the world was not written by a socialist. It was pushed through the German Reichstag in 1883 by Otto von Bismarck, the Prussian aristocrat who had unified Germany through three wars and who, at the same moment, was using the police to shut down socialist newspapers and meetings under a law passed five years earlier. Bismarck wanted factory workers to look to the Kaiser's government for security instead of to the Social Democrats. So he offered them something the socialists had been demanding: protection when illness kept them from work. The law required many industrial workers to join a sickness fund, paid for by contributions from workers and employers, which covered doctors' care, medicine and wages lost to illness. It was a political weapon. It also turned out to be the seed of one of the most durable health systems on earth, and of a whole family of systems that reach universal coverage without a single government payer.
In short: Germany's 1883 sickness insurance law created the model of compulsory, regulated, non-profit insurance funds that most of continental Europe later followed. Germany and the Netherlands now cover nearly everyone through multiple insurers held to strict public rules. The lesson for Americans is that the choice is not only between single payer and today's market; it is about how tightly insurers are regulated and how fairly the money is shared.
A conservative's insurance policy
Bismarck's motives are well documented and not flattering. In 1878 he pushed through the Anti-Socialist Laws, which banned Social Democratic organizations, meetings and publications. At the same time he argued that the state had a positive duty to care for workers. A message from Kaiser Wilhelm I to the Reichstag in November 1881 set out a programme of social insurance: sickness, then accidents, then old age and disability.
The pieces arrived in order. Sickness insurance came in 1883. Accident insurance followed in 1884. Old-age and disability pensions came in 1889. Together they made Germany the first country with a national system of social insurance.
The strategy did not work on its own terms. The Social Democrats kept growing and became the largest party in the Reichstag in the years before the First World War. But the insurance outlived its author's purpose. Workers came to see it as theirs, and every German government since, through empire, republic, dictatorship, division and reunification, has kept and extended it.
How the 1883 law actually worked
The original law did not create one big government fund. It built on institutions that already existed: mutual aid societies, guild funds, factory funds run by employers, and local funds organized by district. Workers in covered industries had to belong to one of them. Contributions were shared, with workers paying about two-thirds and employers about one-third in the original design. The funds paid for medical treatment, medicines and cash benefits during illness.
Two features of that arrangement shaped everything that followed.
First, the funds were self-governing. Representatives of workers and employers sat on their boards. That made them closer to cooperatives than to commercial insurers, and it gave organized labour a foothold in running the system. Unions and Social Democrats, the very people Bismarck wanted to sideline, ended up with real influence in many funds.
Second, coverage expanded by adding groups, not by starting over. At first the law covered a slice of industrial workers. Over the following century, Germany extended compulsory insurance to more occupations, to family members, to farmers, to students, to pensioners. Coverage became effectively universal through a long series of additions. Since 2009, Germans have been required to have health insurance, either in the statutory system or through a private plan.
Germany today: many funds, one set of rules
Most Germans belong to one of the statutory sickness funds, the Krankenkassen. There are far fewer of them than there once were, because funds have merged over the decades, but there are still dozens, and people can choose among them. Higher earners, civil servants and the self-employed can opt instead for private insurance, which works differently and is a long-running source of argument.
What keeps a multi-payer system from behaving like the American market? A few rules do most of the work.
Contributions are based on income, not health. Members pay a percentage of their wages up to a ceiling, shared with their employer. A sick person and a healthy person with the same salary pay the same.
Funds cannot pick and choose. A statutory fund must accept anyone eligible who applies. It cannot charge more because someone has diabetes or cancer.
Benefits are largely standardized. The core package is set nationally through a joint committee of doctors, hospitals and funds. Funds compete at the edges, on service and some extras, not by stripping coverage.
Money is pooled and redistributed. Since 2009 contributions flow into a central health fund, which pays each sickness fund a set amount per member adjusted for the age, sex and health conditions of its members. A fund whose members are older and sicker gets more. This risk adjustment is the quiet engine of the whole system. Without it, funds would have every reason to attract the young and healthy and avoid everyone else.
Prices are negotiated collectively. Doctors' fees are set through negotiations between associations of funds and associations of physicians, within budgets. Hospitals are paid by diagnosis-related groups, the same basic idea Medicare uses. Insurers do not each haggle separately with each hospital, as in the United States.
The result is a system that covers almost everyone, offers wide choice of doctors and hospitals, and spends far less per person than the United States, though more than many of its neighbours. Germans complain about it, as everyone everywhere complains about health care, but there is no serious movement to tear it down.
The Dutch went further toward the market
The Netherlands shows that a country can take the Bismarck model and push it toward competition among private insurers without losing universal coverage.
Before 2006 the Dutch had a split system: a public social insurance fund for most people below an income threshold, and private insurance for those above it. The Health Insurance Act of 2006 merged them into one compulsory scheme run by private insurers.
The rules look like a stricter version of the Affordable Care Act. Every resident must buy a basic insurance policy. Insurers must offer that basic package to anyone, at the same premium for everyone who buys the same policy, regardless of age or health. The government defines what the basic package covers. Insurers compete on price and service, and buy care from providers on behalf of their members. A risk equalization fund, financed partly through income-related contributions, compensates insurers who end up with sicker members. Low- and middle-income households get a government allowance to help with premiums. Children are covered without paying premiums. Adults face an annual deductible before most care is covered, though visits to a family doctor are exempt.
Supporters of the Dutch model say it combines universal coverage with consumer choice and pressure on providers to be efficient. Critics in the Netherlands argue that the market has consolidated into a small number of large insurers, that competition on price has squeezed quality in some areas, and that the deductible discourages some poorer people from getting care. All of those critiques are worth taking seriously, and none of them has led the Dutch to abandon universal coverage.
Why Americans should care about a German law from 1883
The American debate tends to treat universal health care as a synonym for single payer: one public insurer, like Medicare for everyone. That is one path, and Canada and Taiwan show it can work well. But most rich democracies that cover everyone did not take that path. Germany, the Netherlands, Switzerland, Belgium, France and Japan all use multiple insurers in some form.
Here is the argument for paying attention to them. The United States already has the building blocks of a multi-payer universal system. It has employer-based insurance, which is a distant descendant of the Bismarck idea of insurance tied to work. It has the ACA marketplaces, which require insurers to take all comers at community-rated prices and run a risk adjustment program. It has Medicare and Medicaid for older and poorer people.
What the United States lacks are the pieces that make the European versions work for everyone:
- A real requirement that everyone be covered, paired with enough subsidy to make that affordable. The ACA's penalty for going without insurance was reduced to zero starting in 2019, and the system has holes.
- Common prices. In Germany and the Netherlands, governments or collective negotiations hold down what providers can charge. American insurers each negotiate separately with hospitals that have often merged into regional giants, and the prices are much higher.
- A standard benefit package that does not vary wildly by employer or plan.
- No exclusion by job. Losing a job in Germany does not mean losing a sickness fund. In the United States, it often still means scrambling for coverage.
Switzerland, the strictest market of all
A third country rounds out the picture. Switzerland reached universal coverage in 1996, when a federal health insurance law made basic coverage compulsory for every resident.
The Swiss system relies entirely on private insurers for basic coverage, but those insurers may not make a profit on the basic package; they can earn profits only on supplementary policies. Insurers must accept every applicant for basic coverage and charge the same premium to everyone of the same age group in the same region, regardless of health. A risk equalization scheme compensates insurers that enroll older or sicker members. People choose their insurer and can switch each year.
The weakness of the Swiss model is that premiums are flat per person rather than tied to income, so they fall heavily on lower- and middle-income families, even with government premium subsidies. Rising premiums are a recurring subject of Swiss referendums and political campaigns. Swiss voters have rejected proposals to replace the system with a single public insurer, and have also debated limiting premiums to a share of income.
Switzerland shows both the promise and the danger of the multi-payer path. Universal coverage through private insurers is possible when the rules are strict. But if contributions are not linked to income, the system can be fair to the sick and still hard on the poor.
The case for single payer, stated fairly
Advocates of Medicare for All have a strong answer to all this, and it deserves to be stated plainly. Multi-payer systems carry higher administrative costs than single-payer ones, because many insurers mean many sets of paperwork, marketing and claims systems. Risk adjustment is complex and can be gamed. Insurers that profit from denying care, as Dutch insurers can, have incentives that a public payer does not. And the American experience with private insurers, including in Medicare Advantage, where government audits have found overpayments tied to how patients' diagnoses are coded, gives plenty of reason for suspicion.
I think both sides of this argument are partly right. A single payer is simpler and has more power to hold down prices. A multi-payer system can be politically easier in a country where most people already have private coverage they do not want to give up, and where the insurance industry is a major employer. The real lesson from Germany is that the number of payers matters less than the rules they play under. Common prices, income-based contributions, guaranteed acceptance and risk pooling do most of the work. An American reform that delivered those, whatever it was called, would get much of the way there.
The worker who started it all
Bismarck's purpose was to win workers away from socialism. He failed at that. What he did instead was create an institution that working people could hold onto, run partly themselves, and extend generation after generation. The German labour movement fought for decades to widen the coverage his law began, and it was ordinary miners, factory hands and clerks whose contributions kept the funds alive through two world wars and the hyperinflation of the 1920s.
That should be encouraging to anyone working on health care in the United States. Programmes passed for mixed or even cynical reasons can become foundations if people defend them. Medicare was opposed as socialism in 1965; it is now among the most popular things the federal government does.
What you can do
The multi-payer path is not exotic; the United States is already partway down it. Pushing it the rest of the way takes pressure on rules most people never hear about.
- Track the marketplace and Medicaid fights. The topic page on health care for all collects news on subsidies, Medicaid funding, public options and single-payer proposals across the states.
- Comment on the rules that govern insurers. Federal agencies regularly propose rules on marketplace plans, risk adjustment and Medicare Advantage. The open comment periods page shows which ones are accepting public input, with the closest deadlines first, and explains how to write a comment that sticks.
- Ask your members of Congress specific questions. Do they support capping what hospitals can charge? Requiring every insurer to cover a standard package? The representatives lookup gives you their phone numbers, contact forms and latest votes.
- Watch the cost of living side of health care. Premiums and deductibles are part of household budgets; the affordability topic page follows how costs are hitting families.
- Join or support a patient advocacy group. Groups that help people appeal denials and enroll in coverage are doing the practical work of a fairer system now. The nonprofit directory lists health organizations in your state.