Blog

Block Island and the Slow Start of American Offshore Wind

How five turbines off a small Rhode Island island in 2016 became the first US offshore wind farm, decades after Europe, and why permits, ships, costs and politics kept the US behind.

For most of its modern history, Block Island got its electricity from diesel. The island sits about a dozen miles off the Rhode Island coast, a summer place of bluffs, beaches and ferry lines, with about a thousand people who stay through the winter. Its power plant burned fuel that had to be shipped across the water, and residents paid some of the highest electricity rates in the country, especially in summer when the population swells. In December 2016, five tall turbines standing in the ocean about three miles southeast of the island began sending power ashore. The Block Island Wind Farm, built by a Providence company called Deepwater Wind, had a capacity of 30 megawatts. By the standards of the giant projects in the North Sea, it was tiny. It was also the first commercial offshore wind farm in the United States, arriving a quarter of a century after Denmark built the first one in the world. A cable laid along with it connected the island to the mainland grid for the first time, and the diesel generators were shut down. The question of why the richest country in the world, with some of the windiest coastlines, took so long to put five turbines in the water turns out to have a lot of answers.

In short: Block Island's five turbines, operating since December 2016, proved that offshore wind could be built in U.S. waters, 25 years after Europe's first project. The delay came from deep Pacific waters, an untested federal permitting system, local opposition from powerful waterfront owners, shipping laws, missing ports and supply chains, and policy that changed with each administration.

Europe went first, in shallow water

In 1991, Denmark installed eleven small turbines in the shallow water off the island of Lolland at a place called Vindeby. They were modest machines, but they established that turbines could survive salt, waves and storms. Over the next two decades, Denmark, the United Kingdom, Germany, the Netherlands and Belgium built offshore wind into a major industry. The North Sea helped: it is relatively shallow across large areas, and it is very windy.

European governments also put in place what the industry needed to grow. They designated zones for wind farms, ran auctions for the right to build there, and in some countries took on the work of connecting the farms to the grid themselves. They built ports and trained crews. They created stable price contracts so that developers could borrow money at reasonable rates. By the time Block Island came online, Europe had thousands of offshore turbines and a supply chain to match. Costs fell as projects scaled, in the way that new technologies usually get cheaper with experience.

The United States had none of that. It had good wind resources off the East Coast, particularly the shallow continental shelf from Massachusetts to the Carolinas, and enormous wind off the West Coast and Hawaii, but there the ocean drops off quickly into deep water where conventional turbines, fixed to the seabed, cannot stand. Floating turbines that could work there are still a younger technology.

The project that tried first

Before Block Island, there was Cape Wind. In 2001 a developer proposed placing 130 turbines on Horseshoe Shoal in Nantucket Sound, between Cape Cod, Martha's Vineyard and Nantucket. It would have been the first large offshore wind farm in North America.

What followed was one of the longest and most expensive fights in American energy history. Opponents included owners of waterfront homes who did not want turbines on the horizon, some local fishermen, tribes concerned about sacred sites and views, and wealthy figures from both parties. The late Senator Edward Kennedy, whose family's compound looked out over the sound, opposed the project, and the industrialist William Koch funded much of the opposition. Lawsuits, state and federal reviews and political maneuvering stretched on for more than a decade. The developer won most of its legal fights, but lost the war of time. In 2017, Cape Wind gave up its federal lease.

Cape Wind's failure carried a lesson that clean-energy advocates sometimes resist: the tools of environmental review and litigation can be used by people with resources to block projects that would reduce pollution. It also showed that a project sited in a beloved, crowded body of water, without early buy-in from the people who use it, will face a brutal fight.

Building the federal rulebook from scratch

For years, there was no clear federal system for leasing the outer continental shelf for wind at all. Congress gave the Interior Department authority over offshore renewable energy in the Energy Policy Act of 2005. Rules for leasing came later. After the Deepwater Horizon disaster in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010, the agency that oversaw offshore drilling was reorganized, and the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management emerged with responsibility for leasing offshore areas for both oil and wind.

That meant every early offshore wind project was a first. Agencies had to figure out how to study effects on fisheries, birds, marine mammals like the endangered North Atlantic right whale, navigation, military radar and views. Developers had to wait while they did.

Block Island largely avoided the slowest parts of this process. It sat in Rhode Island state waters, within three miles of shore, rather than in federal waters. Rhode Island had invested in planning: its coastal management council produced a detailed Ocean Special Area Management Plan that mapped fishing grounds, shipping lanes and habitat, and identified places where turbines would cause the least conflict. Deepwater Wind worked with local fishermen and islanders. The state legislature backed a power contract. The plan did not end disagreement, but it gave the project a map and a public process that people trusted more than Cape Wind's.

Ships, ports and a 1920 law

Building an offshore wind farm requires specialized vessels: jack-up ships that can lift heavy turbine parts and stand on legs in the seabed. Europe had a fleet of them. The United States did not, and a law passed in 1920 complicated matters.

The Merchant Marine Act of 1920, commonly called the Jones Act, requires ships that carry goods between U.S. points to be built in the United States, owned and crewed by Americans and flagged here. Its supporters, including maritime unions and shipbuilders, argue that it sustains a domestic fleet and skilled jobs that matter for national security. Its critics say it raises costs for everything from Puerto Rico's imports to offshore construction.

For offshore wind, the effect was that developers could not simply hire a European installation vessel to carry turbine parts out from an American port. They used workarounds, such as having U.S.-flagged barges bring parts to a foreign installation ship waiting offshore. That added cost and time. A U.S.-built wind turbine installation vessel was eventually built in Texas, part of the effort to create a domestic supply chain, but it came years after Block Island.

Ports were another problem. Turbine blades and towers are enormous, and staging them requires heavy-lift harbors with deep water and no low bridges. Several East Coast states spent heavily to upgrade ports in New Jersey, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maryland and Virginia, creating jobs in places like New London and New Bedford.

Fish, whales and the ocean floor

Opposition to offshore wind often centers on the ocean itself, and those concerns deserve a straight answer.

Fishing communities have the most at stake. Turbines and cables occupy areas where boats drag nets or set traps, and survey and construction work can disrupt fishing seasons. New England's fishermen, many working family boats out of ports like Point Judith, have pushed for compensation funds, careful turbine spacing and a real voice in where projects go. Some of those demands have been met; others remain disputes. Their worries are not obstruction. They are people protecting a livelihood that predates the turbines by centuries.

The foundations themselves change the seabed. Studies around Block Island and in European wind farms have found that turbine bases can act like artificial reefs, attracting mussels and fish. Recreational anglers on Block Island have reported good fishing near the towers. Whether the overall effect on commercial fisheries is positive, negative or mixed depends on the species and the place, and scientists are still studying it.

The sharpest public argument has been over whales. Starting around 2016, a spate of whale deaths along the Atlantic coast drew attention, and some opponents linked them to offshore wind survey work. Federal scientists at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration have said they found no evidence connecting those deaths to offshore wind activity, and they point to vessel strikes and entanglement in fishing gear as the leading human causes of death for large whales. The North Atlantic right whale, one of the most endangered large whales, is genuinely in peril, and offshore wind projects operate under rules meant to protect it: seasonal limits on pile driving, observers on vessels, speed restrictions and noise reduction. Taking the whale seriously means taking those rules seriously, and also taking seriously the larger threats that have nothing to do with wind.

The slow ramp after Block Island

After Block Island, the next step came in Virginia, where a utility installed two test turbines off Virginia Beach in 2020. The first large commercial projects took longer. Vineyard Wind, south of Martha's Vineyard, began delivering power to Massachusetts in early 2024. South Fork Wind, which serves Long Island, was completed in 2024. Others followed into construction.

Then came a cost crisis. Inflation and higher interest rates in 2022 and 2023 hit offshore wind hard, because its projects require huge upfront capital and had signed power contracts at prices set before costs climbed. Several developers canceled or sought to rebid contracts. The Danish company Ørsted, which had bought Deepwater Wind in 2018, canceled its two Ocean Wind projects off New Jersey in 2023. In July 2024, a blade broke on a Vineyard Wind turbine, scattering fiberglass debris that washed up on Nantucket beaches and temporarily halting work.

And politics turned. On his first day back in office in January 2025, President Trump ordered a pause on new offshore wind leasing and a review of existing permits. His administration went on to halt or revisit approvals for projects already under construction, including a stop-work order against Revolution Wind, a project in the same waters near Block Island. Those fights are covered elsewhere on this blog and in the courts.

Why the slow start matters now

There are two ways to read Block Island's story. The pessimistic version is that the United States lost twenty years, paid more for offshore wind than Europe because it never built the supply chain early, and then saw its young industry hit by a cost shock and a hostile administration.

The more hopeful version is that every barrier that delayed American offshore wind was eventually addressed by somebody. Rhode Island showed that careful ocean planning reduces conflict. States built ports and trained workers. A domestic installation ship was built. Federal agencies developed a leasing system. Unions signed project labor agreements that tied offshore wind to good jobs, and those workers became some of the industry's strongest defenders. Northeastern states with few other large sources of clean power made offshore wind central to their plans.

Here's the case I'd make: the biggest risk to offshore wind is no longer technical or even financial. It is policy instability. A developer can design around whales, ships and storms. It cannot design around a permit that might be pulled after construction begins. That is a concern that should unite people who care about clean energy with those who care, for their own reasons, about the rule of law and about investors being able to rely on government decisions.

There is a rural and working-class side to this that national debates tend to skip. The places that have gained most from offshore wind construction so far are not wealthy coastal enclaves but old industrial ports: New London, New Bedford, Providence, the harbors of southern New Jersey and Hampton Roads in Virginia. Some of those cities had watched their waterfronts empty out for decades. Steel fabrication, vessel crews, port labor and maintenance jobs offered a new kind of maritime work. When the industry stalls, those are the towns that feel it first.

Block Island itself has been an ordinary success. The turbines turn, the diesel plant is retired, the fishing charters still run and visitors take boat tours out to look at the towers. Islanders who were skeptical before construction have, in many cases, simply gotten used to them.

What you can do

See how your state's electricity is produced and how much comes from wind. The site's climate data page shows the U.S. power mix and clean power by state.

If you live in a coastal state, find out whether your state has an ocean plan like Rhode Island's, and whether fishermen, tribes and coastal towns had a real voice in it. Early, public planning is what kept Block Island from becoming another Cape Wind.

Follow the court fights over permits that have already been granted. The court watch page tracks Supreme Court opinions and emergency orders, and the climate policy page gathers reporting on offshore wind and the projects still being built.

Tell your senators and representative that you want projects that won approval to be able to finish. You can find your members of Congress and state legislators by address, along with how to reach them.

Latest on this topic