Blog

Book Challenges Since 2021 and What Library Records Show

The American Library Association counted 4,240 titles challenged in 2023. Here is who files those challenges, how a school district decides, and what the records reveal about the wave.

Every year, the American Library Association's Office for Intellectual Freedom adds up a number that most people never see. It collects reports from librarians, from news stories and from public records about attempts to remove or restrict books in schools and public libraries, and it publishes a tally. For much of the 2000s and 2010s, that tally was a few hundred titles a year, an ordinary background hum of a parent objecting here, a pastor there. Then the hum turned into a roar. For 2023, the association reported that 4,240 unique titles had been targeted for censorship, the highest number it had ever recorded. The most remarkable thing about that number is not its size. It is what the paperwork behind it shows about who was doing the challenging, and how.

In short: Book challenges in American schools and libraries rose to record levels after 2021, driven less by individual parents than by organized groups, lists shared online and new state laws. Districts decide through written reconsideration policies, and the outcome often depends on whether those policies are followed or bypassed.

Counting what can be counted

Before going further, a word about the data, because both sides of this fight sometimes treat the numbers carelessly.

The ALA's figures are a count of reported challenges, gathered from librarians and media reports. Many challenges are never reported, so the true number is likely higher. At the same time, a single challenge can name hundreds of books at once, which inflates the count of titles relative to the number of people objecting. The association distinguishes between the number of separate challenge attempts and the number of unique titles named, and both matter.

For 2022, the ALA counted 2,571 unique titles targeted, at the time the highest figure in the two decades it had kept comparable records. In 2023, the count jumped to 4,240. In 2024, the number of unique titles fell back somewhat, though it remained far above the levels of the years before 2021. Whether that decline reflects fewer challenges, less reporting, or books already removed and no longer available to challenge is a fair question with no single answer.

PEN America, a free-expression organization, keeps a separate count focused on school districts, tracking instances where a book was actually removed or restricted, rather than only challenged. Its numbers for recent school years run into the thousands as well. The two organizations use different definitions, which is why their totals differ, and readers should be careful not to treat them as the same measure.

Who files the challenges

The old picture of a book challenge was a single parent who had read a passage in a child's assigned novel and complained to the principal. Those challenges still happen, and many are made in good faith. But the records from the recent wave show a different pattern.

The ALA has reported that in recent years, a large majority of challenges came from organized pressure groups, board members and elected officials rather than from individual parents acting alone. Many challenges listed dozens or hundreds of titles, often drawn from lists circulated online. Some of the same titles appeared in challenges in districts hundreds of miles apart, filed within weeks of each other.

Groups formed after 2021 to organize parents around school issues have played a central role. Moms for Liberty, founded in Florida in 2021, became the best-known, with chapters in many states. Their members and allies have argued that schools exposed children to sexually explicit material and to lessons on race and gender that parents never approved. Other groups and individuals filed large batches of challenges in particular districts.

The books most often challenged reveal a clear pattern. Year after year, the most targeted titles have been books with LGBTQ characters or themes and books by and about people of color. Maia Kobabe's memoir Gender Queer topped the ALA's list of most challenged books for several years running. Books by Toni Morrison, including The Bluest Eye, have long appeared on challenge lists as well.

How a district decides

Most school districts have a written policy for handling challenges to library and classroom materials. The details vary, but the typical process looks something like this.

A parent, staff member or resident files a formal request for reconsideration, usually on a standard form that asks which book, what part of it is objectionable, and whether the person has read the whole work. A review committee, often including a librarian, teachers, an administrator and a parent, reads the book and considers its educational value, its age-appropriateness and the objection. The committee recommends whether to keep, move or remove the book. The decision can usually be appealed to the superintendent and then to the school board.

Two procedural details matter more than they look. First, whether a challenged book stays on the shelf during review. Many policies, following guidance long recommended by library associations, keep the book available until a decision is made. Others pull it immediately, which means a single complaint can remove a book for months. Second, whether the policy requires the challenger to have read the whole book. That requirement exists because a passage pulled out of context can make almost any serious work look obscene.

In the recent wave, many of the most contested removals happened when districts bypassed their own processes, with boards or superintendents ordering books pulled without committee review, sometimes in response to a list. That is the same pattern that brought the Island Trees board to the Supreme Court in the case known as Board v. Pico, decided in 1982, where the board had set aside its own committee's recommendations.

The role of state laws

Since 2021, several states have passed laws that change how schools handle library materials. These vary widely. Some require districts to post lists of library books online so parents can review them. Some create new procedures for challenges, sometimes with deadlines that push districts to remove books quickly. Some prohibit materials that meet broad definitions of sexual content, with penalties for educators who violate them.

Florida's laws, in particular, led some districts to remove large numbers of books for review, sometimes emptying classroom libraries while staff checked titles. Texas passed a law in 2023 requiring book vendors to rate materials for sexual content, parts of which were blocked by federal courts. Other states, going the opposite direction, have passed laws limiting book removals, protecting librarians from prosecution, or requiring that removals follow professional standards. Illinois, in 2023, became the first state to tie state library grants to adopting the library association's principles against banning books.

Federal courts have reached different conclusions about the constitutional limits on removal. The full Fifth Circuit held in 2025 that public library patrons do not have a First Amendment right that bars officials from removing books, in a case from Llano County, Texas. Readers who want to follow how higher courts treat these questions can check the court watch page.

The fair version of the concern

Many parents who support removing some books are not trying to censor ideas. They are worried about specific passages, often graphic depictions of sex, and they believe a school should not hand those to a twelve-year-old. That concern is legitimate, and progressives lose credibility when we pretend that every challenged passage is innocuous. Some are explicit. Some books placed in a middle school library might reasonably belong in a high school library instead.

It is also true that librarians make judgments every day about what to buy and where to shelve it, and that a library cannot hold everything. Parents are entitled to know what their children are reading and to direct their own children's choices.

Here is the case, as I see it, for resisting the recent wave, even granting those points. A parent who wants to limit what their own child reads already has tools to do it, including, in many districts, the ability to restrict a child's library account. What the organized campaigns sought was different: removal for everyone, based on lists compiled by people who had often not read the books, and targeted disproportionately at stories about LGBTQ people and people of color. A gay teenager in a small town, or a Black student looking for books that reflect her own family's history, loses something real when those books disappear. And a process that lets the loudest voices skip the review that the district's own policy requires is a bad process no matter which side is using it.

There is a lesson for progressives here too. Some on the left have pushed to remove older books, or to drop classics from reading lists, because of language or portrayals that offend modern readers. The principle that protects Gender Queer is the same principle that protects Huckleberry Finn. It is stronger when applied consistently.

Where librarians stand

School librarians have found themselves at the center of this fight, often without having sought it. Many work alone in their buildings, and in some districts the position has been cut or left vacant. In several states, new laws exposed educators to complaints or penalties for providing materials judged harmful to minors, and some librarians have described leaving the profession rather than work under that pressure. Others have described being harassed online after a challenge became public.

The professional standards librarians follow, set out by the American Library Association and its school library division, call for diverse collections, written selection policies and formal reconsideration processes. Critics argue that those standards reflect the profession's own political leanings. Defenders respond that the standards exist precisely so that decisions are made by consistent rules rather than by whoever complains loudest, and that they protect conservative and religious books from removal just as firmly as any others.

What the records cannot tell you

The numbers capture challenges and removals. They do not capture the quieter effect researchers and librarians describe: books never ordered in the first place because a librarian feared a fight, or teachers removing classroom libraries entirely to avoid being accused of breaking a vague law. This kind of self-censorship is hard to measure, and that difficulty should make everyone cautious about claims in either direction. But school librarians in several states have described it publicly, and it is a cost that no tally will ever show in full.

The records also cannot tell you how many students simply went elsewhere: to a public library, a bookstore, an e-book on a phone. For students with money and access, removal is an inconvenience. For students without, it can mean the book is gone.

Inside a review committee

It is worth imagining what a well-run review actually looks like, because most people who argue about book challenges have never seen one.

A committee of five or six people receives copies of the challenged book. Each member reads it in full. They also read the challenge form, which identifies the passages the person objects to, and professional reviews of the book from journals librarians use for selection. The committee meets, sometimes in public, and discusses questions such as whether the book has literary or educational merit as a whole, whether it suits the age range of the school, and whether the objectionable passages are central to the work or incidental. A librarian usually explains why the book was acquired and how often it has been checked out.

The outcome is not always to keep the book. Committees sometimes move a title from a middle school to a high school, or decide a book was purchased without enough review. What makes the process legitimate is not any particular outcome but that the decision is made by people who read the book, applying standards written down in advance, with a record that others can examine.

When that process is skipped, the result is often a list of removals that no one in authority has read in full. Reporting from several districts has described boards removing many titles at a single meeting by working from a list rather than discussing individual books. Whatever one thinks of any particular title, that is not how a public institution should make decisions about what young people may read.

What you can do

The decisions that matter most here are made at board meetings and in review committees, in your own community.

  1. Ask your district for its reconsideration policy and read it. Find out whether challenged books stay available during review and who sits on the committee.
  2. Volunteer for the committee or ask how parents are chosen for it. A balanced committee of people who actually read the books is the best protection against hasty decisions in either direction.
  3. Show up when library policies are on the agenda. Keep testimony short and specific. If you have read a challenged book, say what it meant to you or your child.
  4. Find local library and civil liberties groups through the organizations directory, which lists civil rights and education nonprofits in every state. Many offer training on speaking at board meetings.
  5. Watch your state legislature. Laws on library materials are moving in both directions. Your state legislators can be found by address, along with their contact forms.
  6. Follow the larger debate over free expression and the press, because the arguments about school libraries increasingly echo arguments about public libraries, universities and newsrooms.

Latest on this topic