Blog

California's Proposition 8 and the Long Road Back to the Altar

How California voters ended same-sex marriage in 2008, how a televised-trial fight and two unlikely lawyers carried the case to the Supreme Court, and why it ended on standing.

On June 16, 2008, in the office of San Francisco's mayor, two women in their eighties exchanged vows. Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon had been a couple for more than half a century. In 1955 they had helped found the Daughters of Bilitis, one of the first lesbian organizations in the country, at a time when meeting openly could cost a woman her job. Four years before this ceremony, the city had married them once already, only to have the state supreme court void every license San Francisco issued that winter. This time the marriage was legal under a ruling of the California Supreme Court. Martin died that August, a lawfully wedded wife. Less than three months after her death, California voters went to the polls and decided that no couple like hers would be allowed to marry again.

In short: Proposition 8, approved by about 52 percent of California voters on November 4, 2008, amended the state constitution to end same-sex marriage. A federal trial struck it down in 2010, and on June 26, 2013, the Supreme Court ruled in Hollingsworth v. Perry that its sponsors lacked standing to appeal, letting marriages resume. California voters removed the dead language in 2024.

A window of five months

The road to Proposition 8 began with an earlier vote. In 2000, California voters passed Proposition 22, a statute declaring that only marriage between a man and a woman was valid or recognized in the state. Because it was a statute rather than a constitutional amendment, it could be challenged under the state constitution.

That challenge came after the San Francisco episode of 2004, when Mayor Gavin Newsom directed the county clerk to issue licenses to same-sex couples. Thousands married before the California Supreme Court ordered the city to stop and later declared those marriages void. Lawsuits followed, and they were consolidated into a single case known as In re Marriage Cases.

On May 15, 2008, the California Supreme Court ruled 4-3 that the state constitution protected the right of same-sex couples to marry. Chief Justice Ronald George, a moderate appointed by a Republican governor, wrote the opinion. The court also held that laws classifying people by sexual orientation deserved the strictest form of judicial review. Marriages began in mid-June. Over the next five months, about 18,000 same-sex couples married in California.

Opponents had seen this coming. Before the ruling was even issued, they were gathering signatures for a constitutional amendment to undo it. Proposition 8 was a single sentence: only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California.

The campaign of 2008

The fight over Proposition 8 was one of the most expensive ballot campaigns in the country that year, with tens of millions of dollars raised on each side. It drew donations from every state.

The Yes campaign was organized by a coalition of religious and conservative groups. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints urged its members in California to support the measure, and Latter-day Saints became a large share of its volunteers and donors. Catholic and evangelical churches also mobilized. The campaign's most effective ads focused on schools, arguing that children would be taught about same-sex marriage if the amendment failed. Those ads tested a fear rather than a fact, but they moved voters, and the No campaign was slow to answer them.

The No side, by its own later admission, made mistakes. Its early ads rarely showed actual gay couples, reflecting a strategic judgment that voters would be more comfortable with abstract arguments about fairness than with faces. Many advocates concluded afterward that this was backward. It is hard to persuade people to protect a family you are afraid to show them.

On Election Day, the same California electorate that voted overwhelmingly for Barack Obama also approved Proposition 8, by roughly 52 percent to 48. The marriages already performed were left in a legal limbo.

Two lawyers who had been on opposite sides

In May 2009, the California Supreme Court upheld Proposition 8 as a valid amendment to the state constitution, while ruling that the 18,000 marriages performed before it passed remained valid. That left the state with a strange arrangement: some same-sex couples were married, and no others could be.

For the couples who had married that summer, the next years were an odd kind of limbo. Their licenses were valid, their state tax returns were joint, and their marriages could not be undone. But friends who had waited, perhaps because a parent was too ill to travel to a wedding or because they wanted a bigger ceremony the following spring, had missed the window. Two couples could live on the same block, with the same history and the same children in the same school, and one would be married and the other would be barred from marrying. That situation was hard to defend as a matter of logic, and the federal lawsuit that followed made a point of putting it in front of a judge.

The state's own arrangement also undercut the Yes campaign's central argument. If 18,000 same-sex marriages could exist in California without harming anyone's marriage or anyone's child, it was hard to explain why the 18,001st would.

That same month, a new lawsuit was filed in federal court. It was backed by a newly formed group, the American Foundation for Equal Rights, and argued by an unlikely pair. Theodore Olson had been solicitor general under President George W. Bush and had argued Bush's side in Bush v. Gore in 2000. David Boies had argued Al Gore's side. The two had become friends after that case, and now they joined forces to argue that Proposition 8 violated the federal Constitution.

Olson's participation shocked many conservatives. His argument, in brief, was that marriage is a conservative value, a commitment to stability and family, and that extending it to gay couples strengthens rather than weakens it. Some gay rights groups were nervous for a different reason: they feared a federal suit could reach the Supreme Court too early and produce a loss that would set the cause back for a generation.

The plaintiffs were two couples: Kris Perry and Sandy Stier of Berkeley, who were raising four sons, and Paul Katami and Jeff Zarrillo of Burbank.

The trial the country did not see

The case, Perry v. Schwarzenegger, was assigned to Chief Judge Vaughn Walker of the federal court in San Francisco. Walker made an unusual decision: rather than decide the case on written briefs, he held a full trial, with witnesses and cross-examination, in January 2010.

He also wanted the trial broadcast to other courthouses and posted online. The proponents objected, saying their witnesses feared harassment, and the Supreme Court, in a 5-4 order, blocked the broadcast. So a trial about whether the public's vote could stand took place largely out of public view, preserved in transcripts and, later, in staged readings by actors.

The trial gave the plaintiffs a stage to do what ballot campaigns rarely do: present evidence. Historians testified about how marriage had changed over centuries, including the end of coverture and the end of bans on interracial marriage. Psychologists and economists testified about children raised by same-sex parents and the effects of marriage on health and wealth. The four plaintiffs testified about their own lives.

The proponents called two witnesses. One was David Blankenhorn, a writer and advocate for traditional marriage. On cross-examination, Blankenhorn acknowledged that allowing same-sex couples to marry would benefit those couples and their children. A few years later, in 2012, he publicly announced that he no longer opposed marriage for same-sex couples.

On August 4, 2010, Walker ruled that Proposition 8 violated the due process and equal protection guarantees of the Fourteenth Amendment. His opinion was full of findings of fact, which mattered because appellate courts generally defer to a trial judge's findings about what the evidence showed.

Nobody to defend it

Here is where the case took its decisive turn. Normally, when a federal court strikes down a state law, the state appeals. But Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger and Attorney General Jerry Brown both declined to defend Proposition 8 in court. The appeal was carried instead by the official proponents of the measure, the people who had put it on the ballot.

That raised a question that would ultimately decide the case: did those proponents have standing? Federal courts can hear only real disputes between parties with a concrete stake. A private citizen who disagrees with a ruling usually cannot appeal it.

The Ninth Circuit asked the California Supreme Court whether, under state law, ballot proponents could defend a measure when the state would not. In November 2011, the state court said yes. Then, in February 2012, a divided Ninth Circuit panel affirmed Walker's ruling, but on narrower grounds: California had taken away a right same-sex couples already had, and it had done so without a legitimate reason.

On June 26, 2013, the Supreme Court decided Hollingsworth v. Perry. Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for a 5-4 majority that the proponents did not have standing under federal law, no matter what state law said. They had no personal stake different from any other Californian's. The appeal was dismissed, which left Judge Walker's ruling in place.

The lineup was unusual: Roberts was joined by Justices Scalia, Ginsburg, Breyer and Kagan. Justice Kennedy dissented, joined by Justices Thomas, Alito and Sotomayor, arguing that California's choice to let proponents defend initiatives deserved respect, since otherwise state officials could quietly kill a measure they disliked by refusing to defend it. That is a genuine problem for direct democracy, and progressives who value ballot initiatives on wages or abortion should take it seriously.

Two days later, at City Hall

The Ninth Circuit lifted its stay on June 28, 2013, faster than many expected. That afternoon Kris Perry and Sandy Stier were married at San Francisco City Hall by the state's attorney general, Kamala Harris. Paul Katami and Jeff Zarrillo married in Los Angeles that evening. Clerks across the state began issuing licenses again.

The same day the Court dismissed the California appeal, it decided United States v. Windsor, striking down the federal definition of marriage. Two years later, in Obergefell v. Hodges, marriage became a right in every state.

There was one late chapter. Walker had retired in 2011 and confirmed publicly that he was gay and in a long relationship with a man. Proponents asked to have his ruling vacated, arguing he had a personal stake in the outcome. The federal judge who heard the motion rejected it, reasoning that a judge's sexual orientation no more disqualified him from a case about gay rights than a judge's race or sex disqualified him from cases about race or sex discrimination.

Cleaning up the constitution

For more than a decade after 2013, Proposition 8's sentence sat in the California constitution, unenforceable but not repealed. On November 5, 2024, California voters approved Proposition 3, which removed it and affirmed the right to marry. Colorado and Hawaii voters removed their own dead language the same day.

That vote mattered because of a question that had been unthinkable for years: what happens if the Supreme Court ever revisits Obergefell? The Respect for Marriage Act of 2022 requires states to recognize marriages performed elsewhere, but it does not require any state to issue licenses. In a state with a dead ban still in its constitution, an overruling could revive it overnight. California decided not to take that chance.

Here is the opinion part, briefly: the Proposition 8 story is a warning against treating either courts or ballots as final. Voters took away a right in 2008. A court restored it on a technicality in 2013. Voters wrote it back in, explicitly, in 2024. Rights in a democracy are protected in many places at once, and the most durable protection is the one a majority has chosen.

The people who changed their minds

It is easy to tell this story as one side against another. The more interesting story is how many people moved.

A conservative lawyer who argued for Bush teamed up with the lawyer who argued against him. A traditional-marriage advocate who testified for Proposition 8 changed his mind. And in 2022, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, whose members had been central to passing Proposition 8, issued a statement supporting the Respect for Marriage Act, which paired recognition of same-sex marriages with protections for religious liberty. Proposition 3 passed by a far wider margin than Proposition 8 had, in a state where many voters had since watched their neighbours, coworkers and grown children get married.

Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon did not live to see it all. Lyon died in 2020, in the city where she had married twice. Their story, and that of the 18,000 couples who married in the summer of 2008, is the reason the long road back to the altar ran through California.

What you can do

  • Find out what your state constitution still says. If it carries an old ban, ask your state legislators whether they will put a repeal on the ballot. You can find them, their phone numbers and their recent votes with the representatives lookup.
  • Prepare for ballot measures early. Many marriage and rights amendments appear in low-turnout years. The voting guide lists registration deadlines and mail and early voting rules in every state.
  • Show up for the families, not just the vote. The Proposition 8 campaign taught that people change their minds when they meet the couples involved. LGBTQ community centers and family groups organize that kind of contact; find them in the organizations directory.
  • Watch what the Court does next. The court-watch page lists this term's opinions and emergency orders with the Court's own summaries.

A one-sentence amendment took five years to undo in court and sixteen to erase from the constitution. The couples it tried to stop were patient for every one of them.

Latest on this topic