Blog
Chattanooga's Electric Utility and the Case for City-Owned Internet
How a city power company in Tennessee became the country's best-known internet provider, why other towns stumbled, and the argument for treating broadband as public infrastructure.
In September 2010, the people who read electric meters in Chattanooga, Tennessee, worked for an outfit that was suddenly selling something no private company in America would sell them: an internet connection of one gigabit per second, available to every home and business in its service area. The seller was EPB, the Electric Power Board, a public utility the city created in 1935 to deliver cheap power from the Tennessee Valley Authority. It had strung fiber-optic cable along its poles to modernize the electric grid, and once the glass was up there, its managers asked an obvious question that turned out to be a radical one. Why not let it carry the internet too? A mid-sized Southern city famous for a song about a train had, for a while, the fastest residential internet in the country, and it got there through a New Deal power company.
In short: Chattanooga's public electric utility built fiber for its grid, then used it to offer citywide gigabit internet in 2010, and the service has become one of the strongest arguments for municipal broadband. Other city networks failed, and critics are right to point at them. The lesson is not that every city should build, but that cities should be allowed to, and that the ones that do need patient planning, honest finances and a utility that already knows how to run wires.
A grid project that turned into a phone company
The fiber started as a power project. EPB wanted a "smart grid," with switches that could detect a fault, isolate it and reroute electricity around the damage automatically, so a fallen tree would black out a few houses instead of a neighbourhood. Switches like that need to talk to each other constantly, and fiber was the way to let them.
The money came in two pieces. EPB borrowed through bonds, and it won a federal smart-grid grant of about $111 million from the economic recovery law Congress passed in 2009. That grant matters to the story, because critics later said Chattanooga's success was bought with federal cash other towns would never see. It is a fair point to raise, and an incomplete one: the grant paid for grid equipment that improved electric service for every EPB customer, whether or not they ever bought internet from the utility.
The internet business came before the federal grant. In 2008 EPB won approval to offer video and phone service over its planned network, and the incumbent cable company, Comcast, and industry groups fought it in court and before regulators. They lost. By the time the gigabit offer went live in 2010, the fight over whether a public power company could compete with private carriers had already been argued once in Tennessee, and it would be argued again.
What the network delivered
Start with the electric grid, because that is where the quietest benefits landed. Automated switching meant shorter and smaller outages, and EPB has reported large reductions in the minutes customers spend in the dark after storms. Independent researchers at the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga studied the network's first decade and estimated benefits to the local economy many times larger than its cost, counting jobs, outage savings and the value of faster service. Those are estimates from people sympathetic to the project, and readers should treat them that way; the direction is clear even if the precise totals deserve argument.
Then the internet side. In 2015 EPB began offering a ten-gigabit tier, more than almost any household could use, which was partly a product and partly a statement. More important for ordinary families was what happened to everyone else's prices and speeds. When a public network sets a high floor, private competitors in the same market tend to raise speeds and sharpen offers. That is the oldest argument for a "public option" in any industry, and Chattanooga is the clearest broadband example of it working.
During the pandemic, the utility and the local school system launched a program called HCS EdConnect to give tens of thousands of students from low-income households free internet service for a decade. It is the kind of thing a public utility can decide to do because its board answers to a city, not to shareholders expecting a quarterly return.
The towns that went the other way
An honest case for municipal internet has to spend time on the failures, because they are real and opponents know them by heart.
Provo, Utah, built a city network called iProvo in the mid-2000s. It never attracted enough subscribers to cover its debt, went through private operators, and in 2013 the city sold it to Google for one dollar, while residents kept paying off the bonds. UTOPIA, a consortium of Utah cities, ran into serious financial trouble in its early years, left member cities on the hook for debt payments and had to restructure its model before it stabilized. Burlington Telecom in Vermont ran up losses and a debt dispute that hurt the city's credit rating before the system was sold to a private company in 2018.
The common thread in those stories is not that government cannot run a network. It is that several projects started without an existing utility, without a customer base, and with rosy forecasts of how quickly people would switch from cable. A network is expensive to build and cheap to run, so the whole business depends on getting enough paying customers early. EPB had something the failures lacked: it already served every electric customer, already owned the poles, already ran trucks, billing and a call centre, and could justify part of the build on the grid's own needs.
Critics also point out, correctly, that a city can put taxpayers at risk when it guarantees network debt. The answer to that is design, not prohibition. Some successful systems, such as the network in Wilson, North Carolina, and NextLight in Longmont, Colorado, followed the same path as EPB: an existing city utility, careful phasing and a willingness to compete on service.
The laws that keep towns from trying
Here is where the real fight sits. Many states, through laws written with the support of incumbent carriers, limit or block cities from building or expanding broadband. Tennessee is one of them. Its law allowed EPB to offer internet only inside its electric service territory, which meant that rural neighbours just outside the line, some with no decent service at all, could not buy from the utility even when it wanted to sell to them.
In 2015 the Federal Communications Commission voted to preempt the Tennessee restriction and a similar law in North Carolina, after petitions from Chattanooga and Wilson. Tennessee sued, and in 2016 the federal Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ruled that the FCC lacked the authority to override how a state limits its own cities. The restriction stood.
That ruling deserves careful framing. The court did not say municipal broadband was bad policy. It said that a state's control over its own political subdivisions was not something the FCC could undo without a clear instruction from Congress. That puts the question back where it belongs, with state legislatures, and some have since loosened their limits. It also means that in states that keep them, the people who lose are frequently rural Republicans whose homes sit just past the end of a cable company's profitable route.
Families on the wrong side of a map line
The service-territory limit sounds like a technicality until you picture where it falls. EPB's electric footprint covers Chattanooga and parts of surrounding counties, including some in Georgia. Beyond its edges are hollows and ridges where, for years, the only options were slow DSL, a satellite dish or a phone hotspot that dropped calls. Some of those households could practically see EPB's lines from the end of the driveway.
The utility said repeatedly that it was willing to extend fiber to neighbouring communities if the law allowed. Bills to let it do so came up in the Tennessee legislature in several sessions and did not pass, against steady opposition from private telecom companies that argued a government-backed competitor would undercut them.
In 2017, Tennessee took a different route. The Broadband Accessibility Act created state grants for private providers to build in unserved areas and allowed the state's electric cooperatives, which are member-owned rather than city-owned, to offer broadband. That was real progress, and several co-ops have since built fiber across rural counties. It also illustrates how the politics work: legislators were willing to let rural co-ops and subsidized private carriers fill the gaps, but not to let a city utility with a working network simply sell to the people next door.
A family's choice of internet provider should not depend on which side of a decades-old electric boundary it happens to live on. That is not a left or right position. It is the kind of thing that sounds absurd once it is said out loud.
The other side's strongest case
The best argument against city networks is not ideological. It runs like this: broadband technology changes fast, private firms are better at absorbing the risk of that change, and a city that bets public money on fiber could find itself owning an expensive asset that a cheaper wireless or satellite technology undercuts. Besides, the argument continues, government should not compete with the businesses that pay its taxes.
Take that seriously. Fixed wireless and low-orbit satellite service have improved and do fill gaps, especially in remote places. But fiber's advantage is that the glass in the ground can carry vastly more traffic as the equipment at each end is upgraded; EPB went from one gigabit to ten without digging up the city again. And the "unfair competition" point cuts the other way in places where a single private provider faces no competition at all. A public network is often the only competitor a monopoly will ever have.
Progressives should also admit where we have made this harder for ourselves. Federal broadband money in recent years came with slow, complicated rules. The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021 set aside about $42.5 billion for the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment program, and years later much of that money had not yet connected homes, in part because of layered planning requirements and, after 2025, a rewrite of the program's rules by the new administration. Meanwhile the Affordable Connectivity Program, which had helped millions of low-income households pay their internet bills, ran out of funding in 2024 because Congress did not renew it. Ambition without delivery is a gift to the people who say government cannot build.
The argument, plainly
Here is the case, and it is an argument, so weigh it as one.
Internet service is now closer to electricity and water than to cable television. Children do homework on it, patients see doctors through it, people apply for jobs and benefits on it. When a service becomes that basic, the public has a stake in whether it is affordable and whether it reaches everyone. A century ago, private utilities would not string power lines to farms because the profit was too thin, and the answer was public power and rural electric cooperatives. Chattanooga's network exists because that public power company was still there, ready to do the next thing.
That does not mean every city should build a network tomorrow. It means three narrower things. First, states should repeal laws that forbid cities and co-ops from deciding for themselves. Second, the strongest candidates are towns that already run a utility and can phase construction carefully. Third, public money should come with simple rules and clear deadlines, so households see service in years, not decades.
The beneficiaries are not only urban liberals with fast fiber. They are rural families on the far side of a service-territory line, small manufacturers who need reliable uploads, and older people in small towns who would rather see a doctor by video than drive two hours. Rural electric co-ops, many of them in deeply conservative counties, have become some of the most aggressive fiber builders in the country. That is common ground worth claiming.
There is one more reason to care, and it has to do with democracy rather than download speeds. A public utility holds open board meetings, publishes its budgets and can be voted out, at least indirectly, by the people it serves. When residents in Chattanooga are unhappy with EPB, they know where the board meets. Try finding the equivalent for a national cable conglomerate. Ownership shapes accountability, and for a service this central to modern life, accountability is worth paying attention to.
What you can do
- Learn your state's rule. Find out whether your state restricts city or co-op broadband, then ask your state legislators where they stand; the representatives lookup gives you their phone numbers, contact forms and recent votes.
- Ask your utility the Chattanooga question. If your town runs its own electric or water utility, go to a board meeting and ask whether it has studied fiber, and whether a grid upgrade could carry internet service too.
- Follow the money already promised. Ask your state broadband office how much federal broadband money has reached your county and when construction starts; public pressure speeds up programs that stall.
- Find people already at it. Digital-equity and community groups in many states run sign-up drives and push for affordable plans; the organizations directory lists nonprofits by cause in your state.
- Watch the cost side. Internet bills are part of a household's budget alongside rent and power; the affordability topic page tracks the coverage, and the big tech page follows the companies on the other side of the wire.