Blog

Child Labor Has Come Back to Slaughterhouses and Statehouses

In 2023 the Labor Department found over 100 children cleaning meat plants overnight. The case for defending child labor rules, in plants and legislatures.

The investigators came at night, because that was when the children worked. In 2022, Labor Department staff and federal agents went to meatpacking plants in Nebraska, Minnesota and other states during the overnight sanitation shift, the hours after the kill floors stop when crews hose down and scrub the machines with hot water and harsh chemicals. They were looking at a company called Packers Sanitation Services, a contractor that cleaned plants for some of the biggest meat processors in the country. In February 2023 the department announced what it had found: the company had employed at least 102 children, some as young as 13, to clean dangerous equipment such as back saws, brisket saws and head splitters, across 13 plants in eight states. Some children suffered chemical burns. Some went to school after their shifts, exhausted. The company paid about $1.5 million in civil penalties, the maximum the law allowed, roughly $15,000 per child.

In short: Child labor violations are rising, and the worst cases involve migrant children in dangerous jobs that federal law has banned for minors since 1938. At the same time, several states have loosened their own child labor rules. Here is the argument that both trends need to be met head-on, by stronger enforcement and by defending the laws we already have.

Why the case was a shock, and why it should not have been

To most Americans, child labor is a black-and-white photograph: a boy in a coal breaker, a girl at a spinning frame, the images Lewis Hine made for the National Child Labor Committee in the early twentieth century. Those images helped build the movement that led to the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, which set a minimum working age, limited hours for younger teens, and barred anyone under 18 from jobs the Labor Department declares hazardous. Meatpacking and the operation of power-driven equipment like those saws are on that hazardous list.

So the Packers Sanitation case looked like time travel. It was not. Investigators and reporters had been warning for years that the problem was growing, especially among migrant children who came to the United States alone.

A large number of unaccompanied children crossed the southern border in the years after 2021, many fleeing violence and poverty in Central America. Federal law requires the government to place them with sponsors, often relatives, while their immigration cases proceed. In 2023 The New York Times published an investigation finding many of those children working in factories, food processing plants and construction across the country, often to pay debts to smugglers or send money home, sometimes in dangerous jobs. The reporting won a Pulitzer Prize. Separately, Reuters reported in 2022 that children had worked at suppliers to Hyundai and Kia auto plants in Alabama.

The Labor Department has said for several years that child labor violations it finds have been rising sharply. Its investigators, like OSHA's, are few, and most cases come to light only after a tip, an injury or a news story.

How a meat company avoids knowing

The Packers Sanitation case shows a feature of modern industry worth understanding: the layers between the company that owns the work and the people who do it.

Meat processors hired a contractor to clean their plants. The contractor hired the workers. The workers in some cases were hired with false identity documents, which a busy hiring manager accepted without much scrutiny. Each layer gave the one above it a degree of distance. The processors said they had not known children were on the cleaning crews and that they required their contractors to follow the law. Several of them ended contracts with the company after the findings.

That may well be true. The problem is that the arrangement makes not knowing easy. A plant can run overnight sanitation crews for years without asking how a contractor fills them. The children were in the plants, on the floor, at night, wearing the company's protective gear, cleaning the company's machines.

Here is the case for change. Responsibility should follow control. If a company controls the work site, sets the schedule and profits from the labor, it should share responsibility for who does that labor. The Labor Department has used a provision of the 1938 law, the hot goods provision, which can block shipment of goods made with oppressive child labor, to pressure companies at the top of a supply chain. It has also pushed for agreements requiring processors to audit contractors. Those tools work only when they are used, and they are used rarely.

What federal law actually allows

Before weighing the state fights, it helps to know what the 1938 law and the Labor Department's rules permit. Many people are surprised by both how much teens can legally do and where the hard lines fall.

Under 14. Outside of agriculture, children this young generally cannot hold most jobs covered by federal law, with exceptions such as delivering newspapers, acting and working for a family business in non-hazardous roles.

Ages 14 and 15. Teens can work in many retail, food service and office jobs, but with limits on hours. During the school year, they can work no more than three hours on a school day and eighteen hours in a school week, and only between 7 a.m. and 7 p.m., stretched to 9 p.m. in the summer. There is also a list of tasks they cannot do, such as operating many power-driven machines.

Ages 16 and 17. Federal law places no limit on hours. But these teens still cannot work in jobs the Labor Department has declared hazardous. That list includes meatpacking and slaughtering, operating power-driven meat processing machines, roofing, mining, most work with power saws, many driving jobs and work with explosives.

Farms are different. The rules for agriculture are looser, a holdover from the 1930s. Children as young as 12 can work on farms outside school hours with a parent's consent, and at 16 a teen can do farm work that is considered hazardous. Advocates have tried for decades to close that gap, without success. Children of farmworker families are the ones most affected.

Under any of these rules, the Packers Sanitation children should never have been where they were. The question in the statehouses was not about the hazardous list, which states cannot weaken for jobs federal law covers. It was about the paperwork and hours limits that sit on top of it, and about whether loosening those makes it easier for the worst cases to hide.

There is a reason the hazardous list exists. Federal safety researchers have found for years that young workers are injured on the job at higher rates than older workers. Teens are new to the work, less likely to have been trained, less likely to question an order from a supervisor, and still developing the judgment that comes with experience. Put a tired fourteen-year-old next to a saw in the middle of the night and those risks multiply.

Meanwhile, in the statehouses

Federal child labor law sets a floor; states can go further, and many have their own rules for work permits, hours for teens and hazardous jobs. Starting around 2022, a wave of bills in several states moved in the other direction.

In March 2023, Arkansas passed a law eliminating the state's requirement that 14- and 15-year-olds get a work permit, which had required parental consent and gave the state a record of where young teens worked. Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders signed it, arguing that the permit was a needless bureaucratic barrier between parents and their children's jobs.

Later in 2023, Iowa passed a law extending the hours teens could work, letting 16- and 17-year-olds serve alcohol in restaurants with parental permission, and allowing teens in some approved training programs to do work previously barred to minors. The Labor Department said parts of the law appeared to conflict with federal rules, and noted that federal law still applies where it is stricter.

In 2024, Florida loosened limits on how many hours 16- and 17-year-olds could work on school nights, after a bill that would have gone further was scaled back.

Other states considered similar bills, and some failed. Many of the proposals were promoted by advocacy groups that work across states on deregulation, and supporters framed them around parents' rights and teen opportunity.

The strongest version of the other side

It is worth stating the argument for these laws carefully, because it is not a call to send children into slaughterhouses, and no one in these legislatures said it was.

Teen jobs are good for teens. A first job at a grocery store, a pool or a restaurant teaches responsibility, builds a work record and gives young people money of their own. Research generally finds that moderate work hours for older teens do little harm and may help later in life. Labor shortages after the pandemic left many employers, especially in restaurants and retail, short of workers, and teens were willing. Parents, not the state, are best positioned to decide whether their 15-year-old can handle a job. And a work permit system, supporters said, added paperwork without catching the bad actors, who do not apply for permits anyway.

Some of that is right. Teen summer jobs are a good thing. Moderate hours are not the problem.

But here is the answer, and it is a strong one. The Packers Sanitation children were not doing summer jobs. They were doing hazardous work, overnight, for a company that hid them. The cases now coming to light involve children with no parent present to consent, children with debts to pay, children whose fear of immigration authorities keeps them quiet. Loosening permits and hours rules does nothing for the teen at the grocery store who already had a job, and it removes some of the paper trail that helps inspectors find children who are being exploited. In a period when violations are climbing, weakening the record-keeping is going in the wrong direction.

The labor shortage argument also deserves a straight reply. If an industry cannot staff itself without children, the answer is higher pay and better conditions for adults, not lower ages.

The immigration piece, handled carefully

Any honest account of this issue has to deal with immigration, and it should do so without blaming the children.

The children found in these plants are, overwhelmingly, the victims. Some came alone; some came with or to relatives who could not support them. Some were sent to sponsors who turned out to be exploiting them. Reporting in 2023 found that the agency responsible for placing unaccompanied children had been unable to reach many of them after placement, which prompted calls for more follow-up services.

A tough-on-immigration response can make child labor worse if it teaches children and families that contacting the authorities means deportation. The workers most likely to be exploited are those most afraid to report it. That is why labor enforcement and immigration enforcement have traditionally been kept apart. In 2023 the Biden administration created a process through which workers who report labor violations could ask for temporary protection from deportation while investigations proceed. Weakening that separation hurts the investigations that find exploited children.

People on both sides of the immigration debate can agree on this much: a 13-year-old should not be cleaning a brisket saw at 3 a.m., and the adults who put her there should face consequences.

What stronger enforcement would look like

The case for defending child labor rules does not require new ideas so much as following through on old ones.

Bigger penalties. Fifteen thousand dollars per child, for a company that profits from years of cheap overnight labor, is not deterrence. Members of Congress have introduced bills to raise child labor penalties sharply. With a new Congress taking office in January 2027, that is a reasonable thing to press for.

Responsibility up the chain. Companies that use contractors in dangerous work should have a legal duty to verify that the contractor is not employing minors, and should face penalties when they do not.

More investigators. Wage and hour investigators, who enforce child labor law, are spread thin across the country. More of them, especially working nights in high-risk industries, would find more cases.

Services for the children. Children who are found working need safe housing, school and legal help, not just a lost job. Follow-up for unaccompanied minors after placement needs real funding.

State laws held at the federal floor. Where state legislators propose loosening rules, voters can insist that permit systems and hour limits stay in place, and that any expansion of teen work keep the hazardous jobs list untouched.

What you can do

  • Call your state lawmakers. The rollback bills have all been state bills. Find your state legislators through the representatives lookup, and ask whether they support keeping work permits and current hours limits, and whether they would back penalties for companies whose contractors employ children.
  • Follow the immigration side. Our immigration and ICE topic page collects reporting on unaccompanied children, sponsors and enforcement, which shapes who is most at risk.
  • Support the groups doing the work. Legal aid groups, immigrant rights organizations and worker centers in your state are listed by cause on the organizations directory. Some run hotlines and know-your-rights trainings for teens in the languages they speak.
  • Watch the unions in these plants. Meatpacking unions have been pushing for better staffing and oversight of contractors. Union election results, including at food processing plants, show up on the labor page.

The 1938 law was built on the idea that childhood is not a cost of production. That idea needs defending again, in the plants at night and in the statehouses by day.

Latest on this topic