Blog
Civil Asset Forfeiture and the Land Rover in Timbs v. Indiana
A seized Land Rover led the Supreme Court to bar excessive state fines in 2019. How civil forfeiture takes property without a conviction, and who resists it.
The car was a Land Rover LR2, and Tyson Timbs had bought it new, for about $42,000, with money from his father's life insurance policy. Timbs was struggling with an opioid addiction that had started with prescription painkillers. In 2013, in Indiana, he used the car to drive to meetings where he sold small amounts of heroin to undercover officers, a few hundred dollars' worth in total. He pleaded guilty, was sentenced to home detention and probation, and paid fees. Then the state went after the car. Under Indiana's civil forfeiture law, prosecutors argued, the Land Rover had been used to commit a crime and could be taken. The maximum fine for Timbs's offense was $10,000, a fraction of what the vehicle was worth. On February 20, 2019, a unanimous Supreme Court, in an opinion by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, held that the Constitution's ban on excessive fines applies to the states. The decision was about a single car. Its reach is far wider, because the practice it challenged lets governments take property from people who are never charged with any crime at all.
In short: Civil forfeiture lets the government sue property itself, on the theory that it was involved in a crime, often without convicting or even charging the owner. Timbs v. Indiana held that the Eighth Amendment's Excessive Fines Clause limits states as well as the federal government, giving owners a new constitutional defense, but the deeper reforms have come from state legislatures across the political spectrum.
Suing a car
The legal theory behind civil forfeiture is old and strange. In a criminal case, the government prosecutes a person. In a civil forfeiture case, the government brings a lawsuit against the property itself. That is why these cases carry names like United States v. $35,000 in U.S. Currency, or State v. One 2012 Land Rover. The property is the defendant.
The idea traces back to English admiralty law and early American statutes that allowed the seizure of ships used for piracy or smuggling, when the owner was often beyond the reach of American courts. Seizing the ship was a way to punish wrongdoing when the wrongdoer could not be caught.
Applied to modern policing, the theory has odd consequences. Because the case is civil, the government usually does not need to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt; in many jurisdictions it needs only a preponderance of the evidence, and in some, historically, even less. The owner is often not entitled to a free lawyer, because the right to appointed counsel applies to criminal defendants. And in many systems, the burden effectively falls on the owner to prove the property was not involved in a crime, or that the owner did not know about it, rather than on the government to prove the opposite.
How police keep the money
What turned civil forfeiture from an obscure doctrine into a major issue was money. Congress expanded federal forfeiture in the 1980s as part of the drug war, and the Comprehensive Crime Control Act of 1984 created a federal fund into which forfeited assets flow. The same era created a program called equitable sharing, under which state and local police who work with federal agencies on a seizure can receive a share of the proceeds, up to 80 percent.
Equitable sharing matters because it lets local police get around state laws. If a state restricts forfeiture or requires the money to go into a general fund or to schools, police can bring a federal agency into the case and receive their share through the federal program instead. That gives law enforcement agencies a direct financial interest in the property they seize, an incentive critics say distorts policing priorities.
In many states, forfeiture proceeds go back to the police and prosecutors who seized them, sometimes making up a meaningful part of their budgets. Reporting by The Washington Post in 2014, in a series on highway seizures, documented police stopping motorists, finding cash and seizing it without charging anyone with a crime, and found that many owners never got their money back because the cost of fighting exceeded the amount taken.
Who actually loses property
The image many people carry of forfeiture is a drug lord's mansion or a speedboat full of cash. The records tell a more ordinary story. Studies of state forfeiture data by researchers and by the Institute for Justice have found that many seizures involve modest sums, often a few hundred or a few thousand dollars, taken from people at traffic stops, at airports or during searches of homes. A household's rent money. A small business owner's cash receipts. A car a family needs to get to work.
Those are exactly the cases least likely to be fought. Hiring a lawyer to contest the seizure of $1,500 can cost more than $1,500. Deadlines to file a claim can be short, notices can be confusing, and owners are sometimes offered a deal: sign away the property and no charges will be filed. Many sign. The result is that a large share of forfeitures are never tested in front of a judge at all.
That is why reformers focus on structure, not just on outrageous individual cases. A rule that requires a conviction protects the person who would never have been able to fight. A constitutional defense like the one Timbs won protects mostly the people who can.
The Timbs case
Back to the Land Rover. At the trial court level, an Indiana judge ruled for Timbs, finding that taking a $42,000 vehicle for an offense with a maximum $10,000 fine would be grossly disproportionate and therefore an unconstitutional excessive fine. An intermediate appeals court agreed. But the Indiana Supreme Court reversed on a different ground: it held that the Excessive Fines Clause of the Eighth Amendment had never been applied to the states, and so it could not protect Timbs from Indiana.
That was the question the U.S. Supreme Court took up. Most of the Bill of Rights has been "incorporated" against the states through the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause over the past century, case by case. The Excessive Fines Clause was one of the few that the Court had never formally addressed.
Justice Ginsburg's opinion was short and emphatic. She traced protection against excessive fines back to the Magna Carta and the English Bill of Rights of 1689, and through the history of the Reconstruction era, when Southern states used fines and forfeitures to control newly freed Black Americans under the Black Codes. She concluded that the protection is fundamental to the nation's scheme of ordered liberty and deeply rooted in its history, and therefore applies to the states. Justice Neil Gorsuch and Justice Clarence Thomas each wrote separately, agreeing with the result but expressing views about which part of the Fourteenth Amendment should do the work.
Timbs was represented by the Institute for Justice, a libertarian public interest law firm that has spent years litigating against forfeiture. The case went back to Indiana for a decision on whether taking the car was in fact excessive. After further litigation in Indiana's courts, Timbs won, and the state was ordered to return the Land Rover.
What Timbs changed and what it did not
The ruling gave every property owner in a state forfeiture case a constitutional argument that had not been clearly available before: that taking the property is so disproportionate to the offense that it amounts to an excessive fine. That is a real protection, especially in cases like Timbs's, where the property's value dwarfs the offense.
But Timbs did not end civil forfeiture. It did not require a criminal conviction before the government can take property. It did not change the burden of proof. And the Excessive Fines Clause applies only where a forfeiture counts as punishment and is grossly disproportionate, a test courts apply case by case. A person who loses a few hundred dollars in cash at a traffic stop may have a strong moral claim but a weak excessive fines argument.
The Supreme Court has also declined to expand procedural protections in other forfeiture cases. In 1996, in Bennis v. Michigan, it upheld the forfeiture of a car jointly owned by a woman whose husband had used it to meet a sex worker, even though she had no knowledge of his conduct. In 2024, in Culley v. Marshall, the Court held that the Due Process Clause requires a timely forfeiture hearing but does not require a separate, preliminary hearing on whether the government may keep property while the case proceeds. The owners in that case, whose cars were held for more than a year over offenses committed by other people who had borrowed them, lost.
Justice Thomas, in a 2017 statement in a case called Leonard v. Texas, questioned whether modern civil forfeiture is consistent with due process at all, given how far it has drifted from its historical roots. Justice Gorsuch raised similar concerns in Culley. Those signals suggest some members of the Court's conservative majority are open to a broader challenge. None has yet succeeded.
A reform that crosses party lines
Civil forfeiture is one of the rare issues where the left and the right have largely converged. Progressives object because forfeiture falls hardest on people with little money, who cannot afford to fight, and because it gives police a financial incentive that can shape whom they stop. Libertarians and many conservatives object because it is the government taking private property without a criminal conviction, which offends a basic idea of limited government.
The coalition has produced results in state legislatures. New Mexico in 2015 abolished civil forfeiture, replacing it with a criminal process that requires a conviction before property can be taken. Nebraska and Maine followed with similar laws, and several other states have required a conviction in most cases, raised the burden of proof, or directed proceeds away from law enforcement budgets. Some of these reforms passed with Republican governors and Republican legislatures.
At the federal level, the Fifth Amendment Integrity Restoration Act, known as the FAIR Act, has been introduced repeatedly with bipartisan sponsors, including Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky. It would raise the federal burden of proof, end equitable sharing and send proceeds to the Treasury's general fund rather than to law enforcement. It has not passed.
Federal policy on equitable sharing has also changed with administrations. In 2015, Attorney General Eric Holder restricted a form of federal "adoption" of local seizures. In 2017, Attorney General Jeff Sessions restored it. The practice remains available in some form, subject to whatever policy the Justice Department sets.
The strongest case for forfeiture
Supporters of forfeiture, mainly in law enforcement, make arguments that should be stated fairly.
They argue that forfeiture takes the profit out of crime. Drug trafficking organizations, fraud schemes and other criminal enterprises run on money, and seizing their assets can disrupt them more than prosecuting low-level members. Forfeiture can also return stolen money to victims.
They argue that civil forfeiture is sometimes the only tool available. When a drug kingpin is overseas, dead, or cannot be identified, a criminal case is impossible, but the money left behind can still be seized.
They argue that forfeiture proceeds fund important work, such as equipment, training and drug prevention programs, that taxpayers would otherwise pay for.
Answering it
The first two arguments describe a legitimate use: taking the proceeds of serious crime, especially from organized enterprises. But nearly all of those cases can be handled through criminal forfeiture, which follows a conviction, or through narrow civil procedures for cases where the defendant cannot be found. New Mexico and other states that required a conviction still seize criminal proceeds; they simply require proof first. Reports from those states have not found evidence that the change made it harder to fight serious crime.
The third argument is the strongest reason for reform, not against it. When the agency that seizes property keeps the proceeds, it has a financial interest in seizing more. That is a conflict of interest that would not be tolerated in other parts of government. A judge who kept the fines she imposed would be removed. Police departments should be funded by legislatures, openly, through budgets voters can see.
The deeper principle is one that unites a remarkable range of people: the government should not be able to take your property without proving you did something wrong.
What you can do
Forfeiture law is written mostly by state legislatures, with a federal overlay, and the reform coalition is unusually broad. That makes it a winnable fight.
- Find out how your state handles forfeiture. Whether your state requires a conviction, what the burden of proof is and where the money goes are all set in state law. Ask your state legislators, whose contact details are on the representatives page.
- Look for bipartisan bills and the people behind them. Forfeiture reform has passed with support from both parties. The common ground page shows bills both parties passed together in Congress, a useful reminder of what coalitions are possible.
- Watch what the Court does next. Several justices have signaled interest in a broader challenge. The court watch page carries this term's opinions with the Court's summaries.
- Connect people with legal help. People who lose property often do not know they can contest it, and deadlines are short. The nonprofit directory lists legal aid organizations in every state.
- Follow policing and money stories together. The police accountability topic page gathers reporting on how departments are funded and supervised.
Tyson Timbs got his Land Rover back after years in court, with a public interest law firm on his side and the Supreme Court's attention. Most people who lose property to civil forfeiture never get either. The law should not depend on that kind of luck.