Blog

Congress Averted a Rail Strike in 2022 and Left Out Paid Sick Days

In December 2022 Congress imposed a contract on rail workers to stop a strike, and a separate sick-days measure passed the House but died in the Senate. Here's the argument about what that cost.

On November 30, 2022, the House of Representatives took two votes on the same afternoon, about the same people, with very different results. The first vote imposed a labor contract on more than a hundred thousand freight rail workers whose unions had not all agreed to it, so that they could not legally strike. It passed easily, with support from both parties. The second vote, taken minutes later, would have added seven paid sick days a year to that contract. It passed too, but narrowly, almost entirely on Democratic votes. The next day the Senate took up both. It passed the contract by a wide margin. The sick days measure won a majority of the senators who voted, but not the sixty it needed. The contract became law without it. Rail workers, many of whom had no guaranteed paid sick days at all, went back to work under a deal they had not ratified, and the question of why one measure could pass and the other could not has been hanging over labor politics ever since.

In short: In December 2022, to avoid a national freight rail strike, Congress used its power under the Railway Labor Act to impose a contract that some unions had rejected, largely over sick leave. A separate bill adding seven paid sick days passed the House but fell short in the Senate. The episode showed both the power and the limits of a pro-labor president and Congress, and the sick-days fight then moved to the bargaining table, where unions won more in 2023 than Congress gave them.

A law from 1926 built for trains

Rail labor is governed by its own law, the Railway Labor Act of 1926, which later expanded to cover airlines. It was written after a series of crippling rail strikes, and it is designed to make strikes rare.

Under the act, contracts do not expire in the usual way. When the parties cannot agree, they go through a long sequence of steps: negotiation, mediation by the National Mediation Board, the possibility of arbitration, and finally the appointment of a Presidential Emergency Board that holds hearings and recommends a settlement. Only after a series of cooling-off periods can workers strike or companies lock workers out.

And at the very end, Congress holds a trump card. Because rail is part of interstate commerce, Congress can pass a law imposing terms on both sides and ending the dispute. It has done that a number of times since the 1960s. In practice, this means rail workers have something less than a full right to strike: they can strike only if Congress chooses not to stop them.

How the 2022 dispute got there

Freight rail contracts are negotiated nationally between the major railroads, bargaining together, and a dozen unions representing engineers, conductors, track workers, signal maintainers, machinists, electricians and others. Talks for a new contract began in 2019 and dragged through the pandemic.

By 2022, the dispute had passed through mediation and in July President Biden appointed a Presidential Emergency Board, which recommended a settlement that August. In mid-September, with a strike deadline approaching, the administration helped broker a tentative agreement in talks that ran overnight at the Labor Department. The deal included raises of 24 percent over the five years from 2020 through 2024, the largest raises for rail workers in decades, annual bonuses, and one additional paid personal day.

The deal did not include paid sick days, which had become the central demand of many rail workers. Unions put the deal to their members. Eight unions ratified it. Four, representing more than half of the workers covered, voted it down.

Why sick days had become the fight

To an office worker with paid sick leave, the rail workers' grievance might be hard to picture. It was concrete.

Many freight rail workers, especially those who run the trains, were on call for long stretches, sometimes with little notice of when they would be called in. Railroads had adopted strict attendance policies under which workers accrued penalty points for missed calls, including for illness, and too many points could lead to discipline or firing. A worker with the flu, or a sick child, or a medical appointment, had to choose between going to work sick and risking their job.

The pressure had grown with an operating model the major railroads adopted in the years before, known as precision scheduled railroading. It emphasized longer trains, fewer locomotives, fewer workers and tight cost control. Railroads credited it with improving efficiency and profitability. Unions blamed it for cutting the workforce by tens of thousands, stretching the remaining workers thin and degrading service and safety. Shippers and federal regulators complained about poor service in 2022.

The railroads' position was that their workers' contracts provided other forms of time off and short-term disability benefits that served many of the same purposes as sick days, and that adding paid sick leave would require hiring more workers to cover absences.

The president, the Congress and the vote

As the strike deadline in December approached, the stakes were high. A national rail strike would have halted much of the country's freight movement: chemicals for water treatment, grain, coal, auto parts, consumer goods. Business groups warned of enormous economic damage, and the administration agreed the danger was serious.

On November 28, President Biden asked Congress to pass legislation imposing the tentative agreement the unions had negotiated in September, without changes. He said he was reluctant to override the ratification votes of the unions that had rejected it but that a strike would be devastating.

The House acted on November 30. The measure imposing the contract passed by a wide bipartisan margin, 290 to 137. The House then passed a separate resolution adding seven paid sick days to the contract, 221 to 207, with Democrats voting for it and nearly all Republicans against.

On December 1, the Senate voted. The contract passed 80 to 15. The sick days measure received 52 votes in favor, including several Republicans, but fell short of the 60 needed to overcome a filibuster. Senator Bernie Sanders had led the push for it.

President Biden signed the contract into law on December 2.

What a shutdown would have touched

It helps to be concrete about what a strike would have meant beyond freight.

Most Amtrak trains outside the Northeast run on tracks owned by freight railroads, and many commuter rail systems depend on freight-owned track or freight-employed dispatchers. When the strike threatened in September 2022, Amtrak canceled long-distance trains in advance, and some commuter agencies warned riders of possible disruption. A December strike would have stranded passengers as well as cargo.

On the freight side, the railroads carry a large share of the country's long-distance goods by weight: grain from the Plains, coal, chemicals, lumber, auto parts, and the containers that come through ports. Water utilities rely on rail to deliver chlorine and other treatment chemicals. Farmers rely on it to move harvests. Trucks could not have replaced rail capacity quickly, because there are not enough trucks or drivers to do it.

Who works on the railroad

The people at the center of this fight are often invisible to the rest of us. Freight rail workers live in rail towns across the country, many of them small places on the Plains, in the Midwest and in the South, where the railroad has been the best job in town for generations. Conductors and engineers can be away from home for days at a time, sleeping in company lodging between runs.

The jobs pay well by local standards, which is part of why the fight was never mostly about wages. It was about time: the ability to plan a life, to see a doctor, to be home when a child was sick. That is a demand that resonates far beyond the railroads, and in rail towns that vote overwhelmingly for one party or the other.

The fair case for what Congress did

The decision to impose a contract drew sharp criticism from parts of the labor movement, and it is worth understanding why the president and most Democrats did it anyway.

The case goes like this. A national rail strike in December 2022 would have arrived during a period of high inflation and supply chain stress. Economists and business groups projected large daily losses and disruptions to essentials like water treatment chemicals and food. The contract that Congress imposed was not a company-written deal; it was the agreement unions had negotiated, with large raises. And the alternative, letting a strike proceed and then intervening, might have ended in a worse settlement under more pressure.

Here is the counterargument, and this site finds it persuasive. Congress had the power to impose the contract with sick days included. The House did exactly that. The obstacle was not the Constitution or the Railway Labor Act; it was the Senate filibuster and the votes of senators who opposed the measure. Once the strike was taken away as a threat, the unions had no leverage left in Washington. The workers who had voted down the deal were told, in effect, that their vote did not count, and the one thing they most wanted was left out.

There was a further cost. For years the labor movement had argued that Democrats would stand with workers when it mattered. Many rail workers concluded, with some reason, that when the choice came down to their demand or the economy's stability, they lost. That perception lingered.

What happened next, at the bargaining table

The story did not end in December, and the later chapter is instructive.

Two months after the law was signed, on February 3, 2023, a Norfolk Southern train carrying hazardous chemicals derailed in East Palestine, Ohio. The crash and the controlled burn of toxic chemicals that followed put rail safety, staffing and the railroads' cost-cutting at the center of national attention. A bipartisan rail safety bill was introduced in the Senate by senators from Ohio and Pennsylvania, including Republicans. It did not become law, but the political climate around the railroads shifted.

Meanwhile, the unions kept pushing on sick days, now railroad by railroad. In the months that followed, the major railroads reached agreements with many of their unions providing paid sick days, typically several days a year, with the option to convert unused personal days. By late 2023, unions and railroads had announced sick-leave agreements covering a large share of workers at the major freight railroads.

So the outcome was more complicated than a simple loss. Congress did not give rail workers paid sick days. But public attention, the administration's pressure on the companies behind the scenes, and the unions' bargaining produced paid sick days for many of them within a year.

There is a lesson there, and it cuts in more than one direction. One reading: the system eventually worked. Another: workers had to win at the bargaining table, without the strike threat Congress had taken away, what Congress could have given them in a single vote. Both readings are worth holding.

The bigger argument about the strike right

There is a deeper question beneath the 2022 episode. Should rail workers have a right to strike that Congress can override?

The Railway Labor Act's defenders say yes, because rail and airlines are so central to the economy that a national shutdown is intolerable. Their critics say the override hollows out bargaining, because the railroads know that if talks fail, Congress will likely step in to prevent a strike. That gives the companies less reason to compromise.

Both views have merit. A middle path, which some labor scholars have proposed, would keep Congress's power to prevent national shutdowns but create a neutral process, like binding arbitration, that does not leave the outcome to the political mood of the moment. Any such change would require a new law, and none has advanced.

What is not in doubt is that paid sick leave remains a live issue for millions of workers beyond the railroads. The United States has no national paid sick leave law for private sector workers. A number of states and cities have passed their own, and in 2024 voters in Alaska, Missouri and Nebraska approved ballot measures requiring paid sick leave, all states that voted for the president; Missouri's legislature later repealed its version in 2025. Paid sick days poll well in red and blue places alike.

What you can do

  1. Check how your members voted. The House and Senate votes on the rail contract and the sick days measure are part of the public record. Look up your members on the representatives lookup and ask where they stand on a national paid sick leave law in the new Congress.
  2. See which bills crossed the aisle. The rail contract itself passed with bipartisan support; the sick days measure did not. The common ground page shows bills both parties have passed together, a useful starting point for asking which worker protections might pass next.
  3. Watch party unity. When labor votes split the Democratic caucus, it shows. The party unity page shows how often each Democrat votes with the party.
  4. Follow the new majority. Our Democrats in Congress topic page tracks what the incoming majority is promising on labor, including sick leave and the filibuster.
  5. Track the organizing. Rail unions bargain under the Railway Labor Act rather than the NLRB, but the labor page shows the newest union elections across other industries and the long trend in union membership.

The two votes on that November afternoon told rail workers exactly where the line was. The next Congress will decide whether it stays there.

Latest on this topic