Blog
Defund, Reform or Fund: The Argument Inside the Left Over Police
Minneapolis voters rejected replacing their police department in 2021. The three camps on the left, defund, reform and fund, each make a serious case. Here is each at its best, and where they overlap.
On November 2, 2021, in the city where George Floyd was killed, voters in Minneapolis lined up to decide a question that had seemed, eighteen months earlier, almost settled. Ballot Question 2 asked whether the city charter should be amended to remove the requirement for a police department and replace it with a new Department of Public Safety, which would take what the measure called a comprehensive public health approach and could include police officers "if necessary." In June 2020, standing on a stage in Powderhorn Park under a banner that said "Defund Police," a veto-proof majority of the city council had pledged to begin dismantling the department. By November 2021, the city voted no, by a margin of roughly 56 to 44 percent. Black residents, and Black leaders, were divided, and many neighborhoods where shootings had risen sharply were anything but enthusiastic. That division is the starting point for any honest conversation about policing on the left, because it showed that the people progressives most want to protect did not agree with each other about what protection should look like.
In short: The left's argument over police has three main camps: defund or abolish, reform and hold accountable, and fund with conditions. Each has a strong case and real weaknesses. The Minneapolis vote, the crime trends since 2020 and the reforms that have actually passed suggest the most durable path combines accountability, alternatives for calls police should not handle, and adequate staffing for the ones they should.
How Minneapolis got to the ballot
The killing of George Floyd by Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin on May 25, 2020, captured on a bystander's video, set off protests in hundreds of American cities and around the world. In Minneapolis, a police precinct was burned. The demand to "defund the police" moved from activist circles to national headlines within days.
The city council's June 2020 pledge reflected that moment. But the council could not simply abolish the department; the city charter required a police force with a minimum staffing level tied to population. Changing that required a charter amendment, which meant a public vote. Activists gathered signatures to put the measure on the 2021 ballot.
In the meantime, the city changed. Hundreds of officers left the department through retirement, resignation and disability claims, and staffing fell sharply. Violent crime rose in Minneapolis, as it did in many American cities in 2020 and 2021, including places that never cut police budgets. Chauvin was convicted of murder in April 2021. By the time Question 2 reached the ballot, many residents who had marched in 2020 were also worried about shootings on their block.
The mayor, Jacob Frey, opposed the measure and was re-elected the same day. Prominent Black leaders in the city split; some backed the measure, others campaigned hard against it. The defeat did not end the conversation about policing in Minneapolis. It did end the most ambitious version of it.
The case for defunding or abolishing
The defund and abolition camps are not identical. Some people who used the slogan meant shifting a portion of police budgets to other services. Others meant, literally, building toward a society without police. It is worth stating the strongest version of the argument.
It begins with what police actually do. Studies of police call data have found that a large share of calls involve noncriminal matters: traffic, noise complaints, welfare checks, mental health crises, disputes. Armed officers trained mainly for confrontation are sent to situations that call for a social worker, a medic or a mediator. Some of those encounters turn deadly.
The argument continues with history. Police departments in the United States have roots that include, in the South, slave patrols, and in the North and South alike, the enforcement of segregation and the suppression of labor organizing. Defenders of the abolition view argue that reform has been attempted for more than a century, through commissions, consent decrees and training, and that the same patterns of violence against Black Americans persist.
Finally, the argument points to what actually produces safety: stable housing, good schools, jobs, health care, and strong community ties. Money spent on policing is money not spent on those things. If a city's budget is a statement of values, the defund argument says, many cities have chosen to pay for the consequences of neglect rather than for its prevention.
That is a serious case, grounded in real data about call types and real history. Its weakness is political and practical. The slogan alienated many voters, including many Black voters, who heard it as a promise of less protection. Gallup polling in 2020 found that most Black Americans wanted police to spend at least as much time in their neighborhoods as they did then, or more. And in the short term, cities cannot build the alternative services fast enough to take over the calls police now handle, which leaves a gap.
The case for reform and accountability
The reform camp argues that the core problem is not the existence of police but the absence of accountability. Officers who use excessive force too rarely face consequences. Legal doctrines like qualified immunity make it hard to sue them. Union contracts and state laws in many places shield disciplinary records and make firing difficult. Departments with patterns of abuse are rarely forced to change.
The reform agenda includes banning chokeholds and no-knock warrants, requiring body cameras and the release of footage, creating national databases of officer misconduct so fired officers cannot simply move to another department, changing use-of-force standards, and limiting or ending qualified immunity. The George Floyd Justice in Policing Act, which included many of these provisions, passed the House in 2020 and again in 2021 but did not pass the Senate. Bipartisan negotiations over a compromise bill collapsed later in 2021.
States moved further. In the years after 2020, many states passed some form of policing reform, from use-of-force limits to decertification systems that strip officers of their licenses for misconduct. Some of those laws passed in Republican-led states.
The strongest objection from the abolition side is that reform has a long record of failure, and that new rules are only as strong as the willingness to enforce them. The objection from the right is that tighter rules and more scrutiny drive officers out of the profession and make the remaining ones hesitant to act. Both deserve answers. The answer to the first is that some reforms, like decertification, change incentives in ways that past efforts did not. The answer to the second is that accountability and recruitment are not opposites: departments with clear standards and trusted leadership can attract officers who want to do the job well.
The case for funding with conditions
The third camp, which has grown louder since 2021, argues that communities with high rates of violence need more effective policing, not less, and that the left lost credibility by appearing indifferent to crime. President Biden made this argument directly in his 2022 State of the Union address, saying that the answer was not to defund the police but to fund them, along with the resources and training they needed. The American Rescue Plan allowed state and local governments to use federal relief money for public safety, and many did.
The fund camp points to research finding that additional officers reduce certain violent crimes, especially homicides, with some studies suggesting the effects are largest in Black communities, where the burden of violence is heaviest. It points to the many residents of high-crime neighborhoods in Minneapolis who voted no. And it points to the politics: Democrats who were tied, fairly or not, to the defund slogan lost ground in some races in 2020 and after.
The weakness of this camp is that "fund the police" without conditions can simply mean funding the same practices that produced the crisis. The same research that finds more officers reduce homicides also finds that more officers mean more arrests for low-level offenses, which fall disproportionately on Black residents. More money for a department that does not change can mean more of both.
Where the evidence has gone since
The years after 2020 offered a natural test of competing claims. Homicides rose sharply nationwide in 2020, in cities with every kind of policing policy, and stayed high in 2021. Then, starting in 2022 and accelerating through 2023 and 2024, they fell, in many cities to levels at or below where they were before the pandemic. FBI data and independent tracking of city crime figures both show large declines.
Researchers are still debating why. Explanations include the end of pandemic disruptions, renewed investment in violence interruption programs, police staffing recovering in some places, federal relief money flowing into communities, and changes in the drug trade. The honest conclusion is that no single camp's theory explains the whole curve. Crime rose in cities that cut police and cities that did not, and fell in both kinds too.
What has been tested more directly are alternatives for specific calls. CAHOOTS, a program in Eugene, Oregon, has sent unarmed medics and crisis workers to some mental health and welfare calls since 1989. Denver began a similar program, called STAR, in 2020, and a study found reductions in reports of low-level crimes in the areas it served. Many other cities have launched crisis response teams. These programs are popular across the political spectrum, and they do not depend on which slogan a city's leaders used.
In Minneapolis, the Justice Department, after a federal investigation, reached an agreement with the city in the final days of the Biden administration for a court-enforced consent decree. In 2025, the Trump Justice Department moved to drop it. The city has a separate agreement with the Minnesota Department of Human Rights, reached in 2023, which remains in force.
What the camps share
Set the slogans aside and the three camps agree on more than their arguments suggest.
All three support sending trained crisis responders, not armed officers, to many mental health calls. All three, at least in their mainstream versions, support firing and decertifying officers who commit serious misconduct. All three support investment in violence interruption programs, which use trusted community members to defuse conflicts before they turn into shootings. Most reformers in the fund camp support conditions on new money; most people in the defund camp, when pressed, support a functioning emergency response for violent crime.
Where they disagree is on the size of the police budget and on whether police, as an institution, can be reformed into something trustworthy. Those are real disagreements. But a coalition that started from the agreements could pass a great deal more than it has.
I think the left made its own work harder by letting a slogan stand in for a policy. "Defund" told critics what they wanted to hear and told supporters very little about what would replace the old system. The policies underneath, crisis responders, violence interruption, accountability systems, were popular. The word on the banner was not. Progressives who want to win the next round on public safety should talk about what they are building, and show it working, before they talk about what they want to take away.
The people in the middle of it
Policing debates are often conducted as if there are two sides: police and the people they police. The reality in most neighborhoods is that the same families want both safety and fairness, and are tired of being asked to choose. A mother on the North Side of Minneapolis can want officers to respond quickly when there is a shooting and also want her son not to be stopped and searched on the way home from school. A police officer who joined the force to help can be furious at a colleague's misconduct and also exhausted by being blamed for it.
Political opponents in this debate are mostly neighbors who weigh the same fears differently. Treating them that way, rather than as enemies, is not just decent. It is how coalitions get built, and how measures like crisis response programs passed in cities and states governed by both parties.
What you can do
Policing is mostly local, which means the most consequential decisions are made by city councils, county boards and state legislatures, often in meetings few people attend.
- Show up for your city's budget hearing. Police budgets, crisis response programs and violence interruption grants are decided in the same process. A handful of residents who can speak to specific programs carry real weight.
- Ask your state legislators about decertification and crisis response. Your state legislators' phone numbers and contact forms are on the representatives page, along with their recent votes.
- Vote in local elections. Mayors, sheriffs, prosecutors and council members shape policing more than any federal official. Registration deadlines and early voting for every state are on the voting page.
- Support violence interruption and crisis response groups. The nonprofit directory lists justice reform, health and community organizations in every state, many of which recruit volunteers from the neighborhoods they serve.
- Keep up with the debate as it evolves. The police accountability page gathers news on reforms and investigations, and the party's future page tracks how Democrats are arguing about public safety.
The Minneapolis vote in 2021 was a verdict on a particular proposal, at a particular moment, in a city still grieving. It was not a verdict on whether policing can change. That question is still open, and the people who will answer it are the ones willing to sit through the next budget hearing.