Blog
Dred Scott and the Danger of Trusting the Court to Settle Politics
In 1857 the Supreme Court tried to end the fight over slavery with one ruling. It made the fight worse, and the lesson about judicial humility cuts in every direction.
On March 4, 1857, James Buchanan stood on the east portico of the Capitol and told the country that the question of slavery in the territories was a judicial question, that it was pending before the Supreme Court, and that it would be, in his words, speedily and finally settled there. He promised to accept the result cheerfully, whatever it was. That was a strange thing for a new president to say about a case he was not supposed to know anything about. Buchanan, it later came out, knew a good deal. In the weeks before the inauguration he had written to at least two of the justices, and one of them, Robert Grier of Pennsylvania, had written back about how the Court was leaning. Two days after the speech, on March 6, Chief Justice Roger Taney read the opinion in Dred Scott v. Sandford. The president had told the country the argument was about to end. It was about to get much, much louder.
In short: Dred Scott was the Supreme Court's attempt to end the national fight over slavery by declaring one side constitutionally correct. It denied Black Americans citizenship, struck down a congressional compromise, and helped push the country toward war. Here's the argument: the deepest lesson of the case is not just that the Court got it wrong, but that a Court which tries to settle a live political conflict by fiat puts the country and its own authority at risk.
A family that sued for its freedom, and almost won
Dred Scott was not a theory. He was a man born into slavery in Virginia around the end of the eighteenth century, taken west, and eventually sold to John Emerson, an army surgeon. Emerson's postings took him, and the people he held, to Fort Armstrong in Illinois, a free state, and to Fort Snelling, in a part of the Wisconsin Territory where the Missouri Compromise of 1820 had banned slavery. At Fort Snelling, Scott married Harriet Robinson, who was also enslaved. They would have two daughters, Eliza and Lizzie, whose freedom also hung on the case.
When Emerson died, the Scotts were back in St. Louis, held by his widow. In 1846 Dred and Harriet each filed suit for freedom in the St. Louis courts. This was not exotic. Missouri's courts had, for decades, freed enslaved people who had been taken to live on free soil, on the reasoning that once free, always free. In 1850 a St. Louis jury agreed with the Scotts.
Then the ground moved. In 1852 the Missouri Supreme Court reversed the verdict and, in doing so, threw out its own long line of precedent. The judges were open about why: the times had changed, the state said, and feelings about slavery in the North had made it unwise to keep honouring free-state law. The case was now political, and everyone knew it.
The Scotts' lawyers went to federal court, suing John Sanford, the widow's brother, who by then claimed ownership. (The clerk spelled his name Sandford, and the error lives forever in the case title.) They lost in the federal trial court and appealed to the Supreme Court, where the case was argued, reargued, and held over through an election year.
What Taney actually decided
The Court ruled 7 to 2 against the Scotts. Every justice wrote separately, which makes the case messy to summarise, but Taney's opinion became the voice of the decision, and it went much further than it needed to.
First, Taney held that Black Americans, whether enslaved or free, were not and could not be citizens of the United States within the meaning of the Constitution, and so could not sue in federal court. He reached this by a reading of history in which the founders had regarded Black people as having no rights that white people were bound to respect. That phrase is the one most Americans remember, and it is worth being precise: Taney presented it as his account of founding-era opinion, then adopted it as the constitutional rule.
If the Scotts could not sue, the case should have ended there. It did not. Taney went on to hold that Congress had no power to ban slavery in the territories, which meant the Missouri Compromise, already repealed in 1854, had been unconstitutional all along. It was only the second time the Court had struck down an act of Congress, the first being Marbury v. Madison more than half a century earlier.
Two justices dissented. John McLean of Ohio and Benjamin Curtis of Massachusetts both argued that Congress could govern the territories, slavery included. Curtis went further and took apart Taney's history: free Black men had been voters in several states when the Constitution was ratified, he pointed out, and so had been part of the very people who adopted it. Curtis resigned from the Court later in 1857, after a bitter exchange with Taney over the release of the opinions. He was a careful, conservative lawyer, and his dissent is the one history has vindicated.
The settlement that settled nothing
The justices in the majority seem to have believed, like Buchanan, that a ruling from the highest court would calm the country. The opposite happened.
The decision did not tell Northern voters that the argument was over. It told them that the argument they had been having in Congress, about whether slavery could spread west, had been taken away from them, and that the new Republican Party's central plank had been declared unconstitutional by judges they had no way to vote out. To many in the North, it looked less like law than like a conspiracy among the president, the Court and the slaveholding South. Abraham Lincoln built his 1858 "House Divided" speech partly around that suspicion, describing a chain of events, including the Court's ruling and Buchanan's foreknowledge, that he said looked like a plan.
In the South, the ruling hardened expectations. If slavery was protected by the Constitution in every territory, then any Northern resistance was not a policy disagreement but defiance of the supreme law. Compromise became harder to sell because one side now believed the Constitution had already ruled in its favour.
When Lincoln took office in 1861, he addressed the decision directly in his inaugural address. He did not call for defying the Court in the Scotts' own case. He accepted that a ruling binds the parties to it. But he warned that if every vital question of national policy were to be fixed irrevocably by the Court the moment it reached a lawsuit, the people would have ceased to be their own rulers. That is a paraphrase, and the full passage is worth reading in the original, because it is the most careful statement anyone has made of the line between respecting a court and surrendering to it.
Four years of war followed. The Thirteenth Amendment ended slavery. The first sentence of the Fourteenth Amendment, ratified in 1868, declares that all persons born or naturalized in the United States are citizens. It was written, in large part, to erase Taney's opinion from the Constitution, and it is one of the few times the country has had to amend its founding document to overturn a single Supreme Court decision.
Dred Scott did not live to see it. The Blow family, who had owned him as a young man and who helped fund his lawsuit, arranged for the Scotts to be freed in May 1857, a few months after the decision. He died of tuberculosis in St. Louis the following year. Harriet lived on into the 1870s, long enough to see the Constitution rewritten.
The lesson people draw, and the one this post argues for
Almost everyone now agrees that Dred Scott was wrong. The interesting question is what kind of wrong it was, because the answer shapes how people use it today.
The usual answer is moral: the Court defended slavery and denied the humanity of Black Americans. That is true, and it is enough to condemn the decision. But it does not explain why the decision is also a warning about institutions. A Court could have reached a terrible result narrowly, by deciding only that the Scotts lost under Missouri law. Justice Samuel Nelson's separate opinion suggested roughly that path. The Court that wrote Taney's opinion did something more ambitious. It looked at the most divisive question in the country, one Congress had been fighting over and compromising about for decades, and tried to end the argument by declaring that the Constitution had answered it all along.
Here is the case for that being the deeper error. Courts have power because people accept their judgments, and people accept their judgments mostly because courts seem to be doing law rather than politics. When a Court reaches for the biggest political question of the day and hands total victory to one side, it spends that trust. And it spends it on the very issue where people are least willing to be told the debate is over.
This argument is uncomfortable for progressives, and it should be, because it cuts in more than one direction.
The other side's version of the same lesson
For decades, opponents of Roe v. Wade invoked Dred Scott. The comparison offended many supporters of abortion rights, who saw nothing in common between denying people their freedom and protecting a woman's choice. But the structural point the critics made was a real one. Justice Antonin Scalia, dissenting in Planned Parenthood v. Casey in 1992, compared the Casey plurality's call for the country to accept the Court's resolution of the abortion question to Taney's ambition in 1857. His argument was that the Court had taken a question the Constitution did not clearly answer, removed it from voters, and then been surprised when the argument did not end.
The majority in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, in 2022, made a version of that case when it overruled Roe and said it was returning the issue to the people and their elected representatives. Progressives have strong answers to Dobbs: that a right relied on for nearly fifty years should not have been taken away, that pregnancy and bodily autonomy implicate liberty and equality in ways the Court refused to see, and that "returning the issue" in practice meant returning it to gerrymandered legislatures in some states. Those answers are serious. The point here is narrower. If you believe a Court should be wary of settling a raging national argument by fiat, that belief has to apply when the Court rules against you and when it rules for you.
The same goes for the cases progressives most dislike now. Citizens United in 2010 took a question about campaign spending, which Congress had legislated on for a century, and settled it as a matter of constitutional law. Rucho v. Common Cause in 2019 told federal courts to stay out of partisan gerrymandering altogether. The 2024 immunity decision in Trump v. United States set out broad protection for presidents, on a question the Constitution's text does not address. Critics of each of these argue that the Court either grabbed a political question it should have left alone or abandoned one it should have policed. Supporters of each argue the reverse. What both sides are really arguing about is the same thing the country was arguing about in 1857: who gets to decide.
Humility is not the same as silence
None of this means courts should never rule on big questions. Brown v. Board of Education in 1954 was a ruling on the most divisive question of its era, and it was right. Gideon v. Wainwright, Loving v. Virginia and Obergefell v. Hodges all ended practices that much of the country still supported at the time. A rule that courts must defer to majorities on every contested issue would have left Black children in segregated schools and interracial couples in jail.
So the line cannot be "big questions go to voters, small ones to judges." It has to be something more like this. Courts are at their strongest when they enforce a clear constitutional commitment against a majority that is violating it: equal protection, free speech, the right to counsel. They are at their weakest when they invent a constitutional answer to a policy question the text leaves open and use it to end a democratic argument that was still going on. Brown enforced the Fourteenth Amendment's promise of equality. Taney did the opposite: he read a guarantee of property in human beings into a document that never named slavery, and used it to strike down a law Congress had passed to keep the peace.
The honest version of this standard will sometimes cost progressives a ruling they want. It will also give them the strongest available argument against rulings they oppose, because it is an argument about the Court's role that their opponents have themselves made.
The people the case was really about
It is easy to tell this story as a contest of justices and presidents. The Scotts deserve better. They spent eleven years in courtrooms, against a legal system that kept shifting the rules under them, and they did it while still enslaved. Harriet Scott's own lawsuit, filed alongside her husband's, was folded into his along the way and largely forgotten. When the highest court in the country said they could never be citizens, the answer that eventually came was not a better opinion from the same Court. It was an amendment, ratified by states, written by Congress, demanded by people who refused to accept that the matter was settled.
That is worth remembering in 2026, when many progressives are frustrated with the current Court. The tools that undid Dred Scott were political as well as legal: elections, legislation, constitutional amendment, organizing. Those tools still exist. They are slower than a single ruling. They also last longer.
What you can do
- Read the Court's current work in plain language. The Court Watch page lists this term's Supreme Court opinions with the Court's own summaries, the emergency docket and the Senate's votes on judges. Pick one case a month and read the majority and the dissent.
- Follow the bigger story of the Court. The courts topic page collects the latest reporting on the Supreme Court and the federal bench, from all directions.
- Learn the history behind today's civil rights fights. Our racial justice coverage traces how old rulings still shape voting, policing and schools.
- Ask your members of Congress what they think the Court's role should be. Use the representatives lookup to find your U.S. representative and senators, their contact forms and their latest votes, and ask a specific question: what would they change about how judges are chosen or how long they serve, and why?
- Support the organizations doing the slow work. The organizations directory lists civil rights and legal aid groups in every state.