Blog
Edie Windsor and the Estate Tax Bill That Brought Down DOMA
How a widow's $363,053 federal estate tax bill became United States v. Windsor, the 2013 ruling that ended the federal definition of marriage, and the life behind the case.
The bill came to $363,053. That was the federal estate tax the Internal Revenue Service said Edith Windsor owed after her wife, Thea Spyer, died in February 2009. Had Spyer been a man, Windsor would have owed nothing; the federal tax code lets a surviving spouse inherit without estate tax, on the theory that a married couple's property is a shared life, not a gift between strangers. But the Defense of Marriage Act, signed in 1996, told every federal agency that the word "spouse" meant only a husband or a wife of the opposite sex. Windsor and Spyer had been together for more than forty years and legally married in Canada for almost two. To the IRS, they were unrelated. Windsor paid. Then, at the age of eighty, she sued the United States, and the case that followed reshaped American family law.
In short: Edie Windsor challenged the estate tax she owed because federal law refused to recognize her marriage. On June 26, 2013, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 in United States v. Windsor that Section 3 of DOMA, the federal definition of marriage, was unconstitutional, opening the way to marriage equality nationwide two years later.
Forty years of an engagement
Edith Schlain Windsor was born in Philadelphia in 1929. After a brief early marriage to a man, she moved to New York, where she earned a master's degree in mathematics and went to work in early computing. She spent most of her career at IBM, rising to one of the company's senior technical positions as a systems programmer at a time when very few women held jobs like that.
She met Thea Spyer, a psychologist, in Greenwich Village in the early 1960s. They became a couple a few years later and, in 1967, Spyer proposed. Instead of a ring, which would have invited questions at work about a husband who did not exist, Spyer gave her a circular diamond brooch. It was a small, careful act of hiding in plain sight, and it captures what life was like for gay couples of that generation: devoted, private and constantly managing what others were allowed to know.
Spyer was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis in the 1970s. Over the following decades the disease progressed until she was paralyzed, and Windsor became her caregiver. They kept a home in Manhattan and a house on Long Island and stayed together through all of it. In 2007, when it became clear Spyer's health was failing, they flew to Toronto, where same-sex couples could already marry, and became wives. Spyer died less than two years later.
A law written for a marriage that did not yet exist
To understand why Windsor's tax bill existed at all, go back to Hawaii in 1993. That year, the state's supreme court suggested that denying marriage licenses to same-sex couples might violate the Hawaii constitution's ban on sex discrimination. No state had yet married a same-sex couple, and none would for another decade. But members of Congress worried that if Hawaii did, couples would marry there and then demand recognition everywhere else.
The Defense of Marriage Act was the answer. It had two working parts. Section 2 said that no state had to recognize a same-sex marriage performed in another state. Section 3, the part Windsor would challenge, said that for every federal law, regulation and ruling, marriage meant only a legal union between one man and one woman, and spouse meant only a person of the opposite sex who was a husband or wife. The law passed both chambers by lopsided margins, and President Bill Clinton signed it in September 1996 with little ceremony, in the middle of his reelection campaign.
Section 3 was the sweeping one. It did not just decline to create a new kind of marriage; it reached into every federal program that mentioned a spouse. Clinton himself later wrote that he had come to regret the law and urged the Supreme Court to strike it down. By then, the law was doing exactly what it had been designed to do to people like Edie Windsor, who had married in a country that recognized her and lived in a state that did too.
The tax code's quiet assumption
The estate tax is a good place to see how marriage works inside the law, because it is so unsentimental. Federal tax law allows an unlimited marital deduction: whatever one spouse leaves the other passes free of estate tax. The idea is that a husband and wife build their wealth together, and the government should collect tax only when the property leaves the couple, typically at the second death.
Without that deduction, a surviving partner who inherits a home, savings and investments may face a large bill. That is what happened to Windsor. New York, where she lived, recognized marriages performed elsewhere, so the state treated her as a widow. The federal government did not. The gap between those two answers was exactly $363,053.
This is the detail that made her case so powerful. It was not abstract. Anyone could understand that a woman who had nursed her wife through decades of illness was being taxed as if she had inherited from an acquaintance. And because it was a tax case, the injury was measurable and the government's position was set out in dollars.
A case some advocates were not sure about
Windsor went looking for a lawyer and found Roberta Kaplan, a litigator at the New York firm Paul, Weiss. National gay rights legal groups had their own strategy for challenging DOMA, and some were wary of the timing and the facts of a new case. Kaplan pressed ahead, and Windsor filed suit in federal court in Manhattan in November 2010.
Then something unusual happened. In February 2011, the Obama administration announced that it had concluded Section 3 of DOMA was unconstitutional and that the Justice Department would no longer defend it in court, while continuing to enforce it until the courts decided. That left a strange gap: the government was the defendant but agreed with the plaintiff. The House of Representatives, then under Republican control, stepped in through a body called the Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group and hired Paul Clement, a former solicitor general, to defend the law.
In 2012, the federal district court ruled for Windsor. Later that year, the federal appeals court in New York agreed, in an opinion by Chief Judge Dennis Jacobs, a conservative judge appointed by the first President Bush. Jacobs's opinion held that laws treating gay people differently deserved heightened scrutiny, which DOMA could not survive. The government asked the Supreme Court to take the case anyway, so that the question would be settled nationally.
March 27, 2013: the argument
The Supreme Court heard the case the day after it heard the challenge to California's Proposition 8. Windsor, then eighty-three, sat in the courtroom.
The argument covered three questions at once. Did the Court have jurisdiction, given that the federal government agreed with Windsor? Did the House group have standing to defend the law? And was Section 3 constitutional? The justices spent a good deal of time on the first two, which can look like legal throat-clearing but mattered a great deal, since the same week the Court was wrestling with standing problems in the California case.
On the merits, the argument for DOMA was that Congress had a legitimate interest in a uniform federal definition of marriage, so that a couple's federal benefits would not depend on which state they lived in. That is a serious point: before 1996, federal law generally deferred to the states on marriage, but uniformity is a real value in administering programs as large as Social Security and the tax code. The answer from Windsor's side was that Congress had never before defined marriage for all federal purposes, that it had done so in 1996 precisely to deny recognition to one group of couples, and that "uniformity" meant uniform exclusion.
What Justice Kennedy decided
On June 26, 2013, the Court ruled for Windsor, 5-4. Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote for the majority, joined by Justices Ginsburg, Breyer, Sotomayor and Kagan.
Kennedy's opinion blended two ideas. The first was federalism: marriage has traditionally been defined by the states, and New York had chosen to recognize Windsor's marriage. The second was equal protection, through the Fifth Amendment's guarantee of liberty. DOMA, Kennedy wrote in substance, singled out a class of persons that a state had chosen to dignify and imposed a disadvantage on them across more than a thousand federal laws. Its purpose and effect were to treat those marriages as second class, and the Constitution did not permit that.
The opinion mentioned the children of same-sex couples, observing that DOMA made it harder for them to understand the integrity of their own families. It did not say that every state must allow same-sex couples to marry. It decided only that when a state does, the federal government must respect it.
Chief Justice Roberts, Justice Scalia and Justice Alito wrote dissents, with Justice Thomas joining parts of them. Scalia's was the most cutting, and the most prophetic. He argued that the majority's reasoning about dignity and second-class status would inevitably be used to strike down state bans on same-sex marriage, and that the Court's assurance that it was not deciding that question could not be trusted. Within months, federal judges across the country were quoting Windsor to do exactly what Scalia predicted.
From one widow to every state
The decision went into effect quickly. Federal agencies began recognizing same-sex marriages for taxes, immigration, military benefits and Social Security. Windsor received her refund with interest. Couples who had married in the dozen or so states that allowed it suddenly had federal recognition, and couples elsewhere began travelling to those states to marry.
Lower courts then took Scalia's warning as an instruction manual. Judges in Utah, Oklahoma, Virginia, Texas and elsewhere struck down state bans, often citing Windsor's language about dignity. On June 26, 2015, exactly two years after Windsor and twelve years to the day after Lawrence v. Texas struck down sodomy laws, the Supreme Court decided Obergefell v. Hodges, holding that the Constitution guarantees same-sex couples the right to marry everywhere. Kennedy wrote that opinion too.
DOMA itself lingered on the books, mostly unenforceable, until Congress passed the Respect for Marriage Act in late 2022. That law repealed DOMA and required the federal government and the states to recognize valid marriages performed elsewhere. It passed with votes from both parties in both chambers, a sign of how far opinion had moved since 1996, when DOMA itself passed with large bipartisan majorities.
What her case teaches about how change happens
Here is the argument, as opinion: Windsor won because her case showed what an abstract injustice cost a real person.
For years, defenders of DOMA had described it in general terms, about tradition, about uniformity, about the definition of a word. Windsor's case put a specific widow, a specific illness and a specific tax bill in front of the Court. It made the law's operation visible. Progressive causes often lose when they argue in abstractions and win when they show, concretely, who is harmed and how. The estate tax was an unlikely vehicle for a civil rights victory, which is exactly why it worked.
It is also worth noticing who changed their minds along the way. A conservative appeals judge ruled for Windsor. A Democratic administration that had once been cautious on marriage decided it could no longer defend the law. Members of Congress who had voted for DOMA in 1996 later voted to repeal it. Change of that kind is rarely a single conversion. It is many people, in many institutions, deciding they could no longer explain a law to someone like Edie Windsor.
The rest of her life
Windsor became a celebrity she had never planned to be. She marched at the front of Pride parades, spoke at universities and was named a runner-up for a major magazine's person of the year. She told interviewers repeatedly that the case was a love story more than a legal one. In 2016 she married again, to Judith Kasen. She died in New York on September 12, 2017, at eighty-eight.
The brooch, the long engagement, the decades of caregiving and the tax bill make her story easy to tell. But what it really shows is that ordinary obligations, like paying taxes and caring for a sick spouse, are where the law meets people's lives. The fight for equality often looks grand from a distance. Up close, it is paperwork, and what the paperwork says about whose family counts.
What you can do
- Make sure your own paperwork matches your family. Marriage is now recognized everywhere, but wills, beneficiary forms and health care proxies still matter for every couple, married or not. This is general information, not legal advice; a local legal aid group or a family lawyer can help, and you can find legal aid and LGBTQ+ nonprofits in your state through the organizations directory.
- Thank, or question, the people who will decide the next fight. Ask your members of Congress whether they supported the Respect for Marriage Act and whether they will defend it. Look them up by address to see their contact details and latest votes.
- Watch the votes that cross party lines. The repeal of DOMA passed with Republican and Democratic votes. The common-ground tracker shows bills both parties passed together, which is where durable protections usually come from.
- Read how marriage law keeps moving. The LGBTQ rights topic page collects reporting on family law, recognition and the courts.
Edie Windsor paid a bill she should never have received. The refund she won, with interest, went to every married couple in the country who had been told their vows meant nothing to Washington.