Blog
Encampment Sweeps Move People Around Without Housing Them
The argument that encampment sweeps, from Newsom's 2024 order onward, spend public money and lose track of people unless a real place to live comes with them, and what works instead.
On July 25, 2024, less than a month after the Supreme Court said cities could fine people for sleeping outdoors, California's governor signed an executive order telling state agencies to clear homeless encampments from the property they control. The order asked them to give notice before a cleanup, to store people's belongings, to coordinate with local service providers and to offer shelter where it existed. It also encouraged cities and counties to adopt similar policies, and the governor made clear that state money to local governments would come with expectations. In the weeks that followed, cameras caught him helping to clean up a camp in Los Angeles. The image was meant to show resolve, and it did. The question this post asks is what happened to the people who had been living there, because that is the only question that tells you whether a sweep worked.
In short: This is an argument: clearing encampments without offering housing spends public money, destroys documents and medicine, and scatters people out of reach of the workers trying to help them. Cleanups can be part of a serious plan, but only when a place to live comes with them, and the evidence for housing-led approaches is much stronger than the evidence for sweeps.
What a sweep looks like from the inside
Most people who have never lived in a tent see a sweep from the outside: a cleared sidewalk, trucks hauling away debris, a park returned to public use. From the inside, it looks different.
A typical cleanup starts with notice, a paper posted on tents or handed to residents saying that the area will be cleared on a given day. Some people leave before the date and move a few blocks away. On the day itself, workers and police arrive, residents gather what they can carry, and the rest goes into trucks. Policies usually say that personal property will be bagged and stored for a period so owners can retrieve it. In practice, outreach workers and homeless residents across many cities have described losing tents, sleeping bags, identification, birth certificates, prescription medications and phones, either thrown out as trash or stored somewhere the owner never manages to reach.
Each of those losses has a cost that shows up later. Without identification, a person cannot easily apply for housing, benefits or a job. Without a phone, a caseworker cannot reach them when a housing unit opens. Without medication, someone with a psychiatric illness or an infection gets sicker. A housing application that took months to assemble can be lost in an afternoon.
Where people go after
The people leave, but they do not disappear. They move to another block, under another overpass, into a creek bed, farther from services and from the outreach teams who knew them. Workers in several cities have reported that after a sweep they lose track of clients for weeks or permanently. The relationship of trust built over months, often the thing that finally persuades someone to accept housing, breaks.
Researchers have tried to estimate the health effects. A modeling study published in JAMA in 2023 projected that repeated involuntary displacement of homeless people who use drugs, in a set of American cities, could lead over ten years to substantial increases in overdose deaths and hospitalizations, by disrupting treatment and contact with health workers. A model is not a measurement, and its assumptions can be argued over, but it fits what outreach workers describe: when people are scattered, the systems trying to keep them alive lose contact with them.
Who is actually in the tents
Debates about encampments often proceed as if the people in them were a single type, usually imagined as a man with an untreated addiction who refuses help. Some residents fit that picture. Many do not.
Outreach workers describe camps that include people who work, sometimes full time, but cannot afford a deposit and first month's rent in a city where a modest apartment costs more than their paycheck. Older adults who lost an apartment after a spouse died and the household income fell by half. Young people who aged out of foster care with no family to fall back on. Veterans. People recently released from prison or jail with nowhere to go. Women who fled abusive homes and found shelters full. People with serious mental illnesses, some of whom have cycled through hospitals, jails and the street for years.
That variety matters because each group needs something different, and a sweep treats them all the same. A working couple living in a car needs a deposit and a landlord willing to rent to them. A man with schizophrenia needs supportive housing with staff on site. A woman fleeing violence needs a safe, confidential place to stay. None of those needs is met by moving a tent across the street.
It also matters for how we talk about the people involved. A person living outside is a neighbour in the most literal sense: they live in the same city, often in the same neighbourhood where they once had an apartment. Studies of homeless populations in many places have found that most people experiencing homelessness became homeless in the area where they are now living, rather than arriving from elsewhere to take advantage of services. Treating them as an alien problem to be moved out of view makes it easier to avoid the harder conversation about why so many of our neighbours cannot afford a home.
The language we use shapes the policies we tolerate. Calling a camp a blight invites removal. Calling it a group of neighbours without housing invites the next question: where will they live?
The public money question
Sweeps are not cheap. They require crews, trucks, police time, storage facilities, and cleanup of the hazards that encampments leave behind. Cities that clear the same areas repeatedly pay those costs again and again. Several cities have released figures showing millions of dollars spent on cleanups each year, with little to show in terms of people housed.
California's own spending raises a parallel question. In 2024 the state auditor reported that the state had spent billions of dollars on homelessness programs over five years without consistently tracking whether those programs reduced homelessness. That finding cut against everyone: against advocates who wanted more money with fewer strings, and against officials who promised that spending was working. It should also cut against sweeps, which are rarely measured by the one outcome that matters, how many people ended up in stable housing.
Here is the uncomfortable math. If a camp is cleared and its residents return or move nearby within weeks, the city has spent money to move the problem rather than solve it. If, instead, the money that pays for repeated cleanups helped pay for apartments or supportive housing, the camp would stay empty because its residents would be somewhere else, indoors.
The fair case for clearing camps
I want to be careful here, because the case for cleanups is real, and progressives who wave it away lose the argument with voters, including many who live in or near encampments themselves.
Large camps can be dangerous, most of all to the people who live in them. Fires spread fast among tents. Violence, including sexual violence, is common. Drug dealing can take root. Rats and disease follow trash. Neighbors, including working families in the low-income neighbourhoods where many camps sit, have every right to walk to school or a bus stop without stepping into the street. Small business owners are not villains for wanting their doorways clear. Disability advocates have pointed out that blocked sidewalks are a civil rights issue for wheelchair users.
There is also a case that the status quo before the Supreme Court's ruling was not working. Cities had become afraid to act at all, and some encampments grew for years. Newsom, a Democrat who had spent heavily on homelessness programs, argued that local governments had used legal uncertainty as an excuse not to act, and that the state would no longer fund cities that tolerated permanent camps. That is a defensible position for an official accountable to voters who are tired of the visible suffering on their streets.
So the honest question is not whether camps should ever be cleared. It is what has to come with a cleanup for it to mean something.
What makes a cleanup more than a relocation
Cities that have made real progress tend to treat clearing a camp as the last step of a process, not the first. The pattern looks something like this.
Outreach workers spend weeks or months in an encampment, learning who lives there, what each person needs and what would get them inside. Housing units are lined up before the camp closes: apartments rented through vouchers, supportive housing with on-site services, or at least shelter beds with privacy and the ability to bring partners, pets and possessions. People's documents are collected and kept safe. When the camp closes, most residents move into something specific, and the cleanup is mostly removing what they left behind.
Houston's experience is the most cited example. Over about a decade, the city and its partners cut the number of homeless people by more than half by coordinating dozens of agencies and nonprofits under a single system and moving people straight into apartments with support. The city did close encampments, but generally after the people living there had been offered and moved into housing. The approach was led by officials of both parties, and it was not cheap, but it worked by the measure that counts.
Housing First, the model behind that approach, simply means offering housing without requiring people to first get sober or complete treatment, on the theory that it is easier to address addiction and illness from a stable home. Studies have consistently found that it keeps most participants housed. Critics, including the current federal administration, argue that it neglects treatment and that results on addiction and mental health are weaker than its supporters claim. That debate is worth having. But the alternative being offered in many places is not treatment-first housing; it is no housing, just enforcement.
Blue states, the Trump administration and the shape of the fight
The politics have shifted in ways that do not fit the usual partisan lines. Democratic governors and mayors in California and elsewhere have embraced tougher enforcement, partly in response to voters' frustration. The federal government under the Trump administration has gone further, issuing an executive order in 2025 that moved federal policy away from Housing First and toward conditions on assistance and civil commitment for people with serious mental illness or addiction.
That creates an awkward situation for blue states. If they want to show that their approach differs from the federal one, they have to show results: fewer people on the street because more people are housed, not because they have been pushed out of sight. California voters narrowly approved a 2024 bond measure, Proposition 1, to fund treatment beds and housing for people with mental illness and addiction. Projects like that, along with converting motels into housing as the state did during the pandemic, are the parts of the blue-state response that can actually reduce the number of people sleeping outside. Sweeps without them simply mirror the federal approach with better branding.
Progressives also have to own the supply problem, and own it out loud rather than in a footnote. California's high rents are the single biggest driver of its homelessness, and those rents are high in large part because the state and its cities made it slow and costly to build. Reforms in recent years have loosened some of those rules. Every month of delay on a housing project is a month more people spend outside. A governor who orders camps cleared while cities in his own state sit on stalled apartment permits is pulling one lever hard and leaving the other untouched. The two have to move together, or the camps simply reappear a few blocks away.
What you can do
- Ask what comes after. When your city plans a camp cleanup, ask council members and the mayor's office a simple question: how many of the people living there have been offered housing, and where will they sleep the night after? Public answers create accountability.
- Follow where the money goes. City and state budgets show how much is spent on enforcement and cleanup versus housing and services. The homelessness topic page collects current reporting on how cities are spending.
- Help the people who keep track of people. Outreach groups and legal aid organizations help homeless residents protect documents and get to housing. The organizations directory lists housing groups and legal aid by state.
- Tell your state legislators what you want funded. State budgets decide whether supportive housing and treatment beds get built. Your own legislators, with a number to call and a form to write to, are one address away on the representatives lookup.
- Watch the blue-state fights. How states respond to federal policy on homelessness, and to each other, is tracked on the blue states vs. Trump topic page.
A cleared sidewalk is easy to photograph and easy to put in a campaign ad. A person who stays housed for a year is not. The second is the one worth paying for.