Blog
Florida Voted for a $15 Minimum Wage the Same Year It Voted for Trump
In 2020 Florida backed Trump and a $15 minimum wage on the same ballot. The case that higher pay wins across party lines, the strongest objections and what Congress keeps missing.
Florida's constitution sets a high bar for amending it: since 2006, a proposed amendment needs 60 percent of the vote to pass. In November 2020, Amendment 2, which would raise the state's minimum wage step by step to $15 an hour, cleared that bar with about 61 percent. On the very same ballots, Florida voters gave Donald Trump the state's electoral votes by a margin of roughly three points, a wider win than he had managed four years before. Do the arithmetic and something remarkable falls out. A large number of people walked into a booth, voted for a Republican president who had never championed a $15 wage, and then voted for a $15 wage. The campaign had been bankrolled largely by John Morgan, a well-known Orlando personal-injury lawyer who had also financed Florida's medical marijuana amendment. On September 30, 2026, the last scheduled step took effect, and Florida's minimum wage reached $15. A state many national Democrats had stopped thinking they could win had done what Congress, under both parties, had not.
In short: Here is the argument: higher minimum wages are among the most popular economic policies in America, and they win in red states when voters can decide them directly. Florida in 2020 is the clearest case, but not the only one. Progressives should treat the wage as a cross-party cause, take its critics' best points seriously, and stop leaving the issue to ballot measures alone.
The ballot record nobody in Washington reads
Florida did not invent this pattern. It had already voted, in 2004, to set a state minimum wage above the federal one and to raise it with inflation each year. And other states that vote Republican for president have done the same thing again and again.
In 2018, voters in Arkansas and Missouri approved minimum wage increases by wide margins, at a moment when both states were sending Republicans to Washington. In 2022, Nebraska voters passed an increase to $15 by 2026. In 2024, as Trump carried Missouri and Alaska, voters in both states approved higher wages and paid sick leave.
There are counterexamples, and they are worth noting so this does not become a fairy tale. In 2024, California's Proposition 32, which would have raised the state minimum to $18, narrowly failed, even in a deep-blue state. Massachusetts voters that year rejected a measure to phase out the lower minimum wage for tipped workers. A measure's details, its size, its timing and its opponents' money all matter. But the overall record is striking. When the question is a clearly described raise for low-wage workers, voters in red, purple and blue states have said yes far more often than no.
Why it wins: a theory
Why would someone vote for Trump and for a $15 wage on the same day? Several explanations fit the evidence, and they are not exclusive.
Partisanship and policy are different things. Most voters do not choose a party by checking its platform item by item. They vote for a party based on identity, culture, trust and a general sense of who is on their side. Asked a specific policy question, they answer it on its own terms.
Work is a shared value. The minimum wage is about pay for people who work. It does not ask voters to accept a new government program or a new benefit. Conservatives who value work and self-reliance can see it as making work pay. Progressives can see it as fairness. Both can vote yes.
Prices are concrete. Voters know what rent, groceries and car insurance cost. A full-time job at the old federal minimum of $7.25 pays roughly $15,000 a year before taxes. People do not need an economist to tell them that is not enough to live on anywhere in the country.
The opponents are not sympathetic. Business groups oppose most of these measures, but restaurant chains and large retailers do not make compelling messengers against raising pay for their own workers.
The best case against, answered
The standard objection to minimum wage increases is serious and deserves a real answer.
The argument goes like this: a minimum wage is a price floor. Set it too high, and employers will hire fewer people, cut hours, automate or raise prices. The workers hurt most will be the least experienced and least skilled, young people looking for a first job, people in rural areas where wages and costs are lower, and small businesses with thin margins. A single national number, the critics add, ignores the enormous differences between a city like San Francisco and a small town in Mississippi.
There is evidence on both sides, and economists still argue about it. A famous 1994 study by David Card and Alan Krueger compared fast-food restaurants in New Jersey, which raised its minimum wage, and nearby Pennsylvania, which did not, and found no loss of employment. That study launched decades of research, much of which has found that moderate increases have small or no effects on overall employment, while raising the pay of low-wage workers and reducing turnover. Other studies, especially of large increases, have found some job or hours losses.
The Congressional Budget Office captured the trade-off in a 2019 analysis of a federal $15 wage phased in over several years. Its central estimate was that millions of workers would get raises and that more than a million people would be lifted out of poverty, while a similar number of jobs could be lost, with a wide range of uncertainty around both numbers.
So here is my answer to the objection. The critics are right that size and speed matter, and right that local costs differ. That is an argument for phasing increases in, as Florida did over five years, and for indexing them to inflation afterward so they do not lose value and then need a huge catch-up. It is also an argument for the approach many states have taken, a meaningful federal floor with states free to go higher. It is not an argument for leaving a national wage frozen for well over a decade, which is what happened.
The frozen floor in Washington
The federal minimum wage has been $7.25 an hour since July 24, 2009. That is the longest stretch without an increase since the federal minimum was created in 1938. Inflation has eaten a large share of its value since then.
Both parties share the blame. When Democrats controlled the House in 2019, they passed the Raise the Wage Act to reach $15 gradually, and it died in the Republican Senate. When Democrats had the presidency and narrow control of both chambers in 2021, an amendment to add a $15 wage to the pandemic relief bill failed in the Senate, with eight members of the Democratic caucus voting against it along with every Republican. Republicans, for their part, have generally opposed any federal increase, though a few have floated more modest raises paired with requirements for employers to verify workers' legal status.
That history is an uncomfortable fact for progressives. An issue that wins majorities in Florida and Missouri could not win a majority of Democratic senators when it counted. Part of the reason is that Senate seats from rural and conservative states are held by members who fear business opposition more than they trust ballot results. Part of it is that a single $15 number looked too high for some lower-cost states. The ballot results suggest that fear was overdone.
What happens after voters say yes
A win at the ballot box does not end the fight. In Missouri, after voters passed paid sick leave and a higher wage in 2024, the legislature in 2025 repealed the sick leave requirement and ended the automatic inflation adjustment for future years. Lawmakers argued that they were protecting small businesses and the state's economy. Supporters of the measure argued that legislators had overturned a clear decision by voters only months after it was made.
Florida's increase, written into the constitution, was harder to undo. Even so, the phase-in years were a test. Prices rose sharply across the country in 2021 and 2022, and Florida's housing costs climbed especially fast. A $15 wage in 2026 buys less than it would have when voters approved it, which is exactly why indexing after the final step matters.
There is also a gap the minimum wage alone cannot close. Housing, child care and health care are the costs that push working families under. A higher wage helps, and it is not enough by itself. Progressives who want to keep winning on affordability need a fuller agenda, including building far more homes, which in many blue cities has been slowed by the permitting rules and local vetoes that progressives themselves have sometimes defended.
Why progressives should claim this as common ground
The argument for treating the minimum wage as a cross-party cause is not that it will magically convert Republican voters. It is that it already has the support of many of them, and acting as if it does not wastes an opening.
When progressives talk about wages as part of a broad ideological package, some voters hear a cultural signal and tune out. When they talk about wages the way the Florida campaign did, simply as fair pay for hard work, voters of every stripe hear something they already believe. That does not require abandoning other commitments. It requires leading with the things most people share.
It also requires respect. A woman in Pensacola who voted for Trump and for Amendment 2 is not confused. She is someone who wants a president she trusts and a raise for the cashier at her grocery store, maybe for herself. A movement that cannot imagine her as an ally is not going to build a majority.
How a phase-in works in practice
The details of Amendment 2 explain a lot about why it could pass and why it did not cause the disruption opponents warned about.
The increase came in steps. The minimum rose to $10 on September 30, 2021, and then by a dollar every year on the same date until it reached $15 in 2026. After that, the amendment returns the state to automatic annual inflation adjustments, the system Florida voters had first approved back in 2004. The gradual schedule gave employers years to plan, and it let the labor market adjust as prices and wages were moving anyway.
Tipped workers were included. Florida's tipped minimum wage is set as the regular minimum minus a fixed amount, so as the regular wage climbed, the tipped wage climbed with it.
What the amendment could not change is how much power Florida's legislature keeps over local pay. State law bars cities and counties from setting their own minimum wages, and in 2024 the legislature went further, preventing local governments from requiring certain wage and heat-protection standards from employers. Miami and Orlando cannot decide that their higher costs justify a higher floor than Pensacola's. That is a pattern across many states, where legislatures preempt cities from going further on wages, paid leave or worker protections.
This is where the ballot measure matters as a pressure valve. In states where legislatures block local action and Congress has not acted, citizen initiatives have been the only path to a raise. About half the states allow some form of citizen initiative. In the other half, including some with very low wage floors, voters have no direct way to do what Floridians did.
It is worth being clear-eyed about what initiatives cannot do. They are expensive to run, and Florida's was possible partly because a single wealthy backer was willing to pay for signature gathering and advertising. They tend to produce one-time numbers that legislatures can later chip away at, as Missouri showed. And they put a policy question to voters without the bargaining that comes with legislation, which can be good or bad depending on the question. None of that weakens the main point. When ordinary voters in a red state are given a clear choice about pay for low-wage work, they keep choosing the raise. Politicians in both parties who claim to speak for working people should take the hint and stop waiting for a ballot measure to do their jobs for them. A raise that a majority of Floridians wanted should not have required a lawyer's checkbook and a constitutional amendment to deliver.
What you can do
A raise that voters approve can be indexed, expanded, delayed or repealed. Paying attention after election day is most of the work.
- Check the number in your state. The state minimum wage table lists every state's current minimum wage, so you can see where yours stands against the federal floor and against neighbouring states.
- See the bigger picture. The inequality dashboard tracks real wages, the minimum wage over time and the share of wealth held by the top 1 percent and the bottom half, which is useful context for any argument about pay.
- Watch the workplace fights. Raises also come through bargaining. The labor tracker shows the newest union elections the NLRB has counted and who won.
- Get ready for the next ballot measure. If your state allows initiatives, the voters who decide them need to be registered. The voting page has registration deadlines and mail and early voting rules for every state.
- Follow the cost-of-living debate. The affordability topic page gathers reporting on wages, rent, groceries and the policies that move them.
Florida's last step to $15 took effect quietly, on a Wednesday in September, without a ceremony. Somewhere a line cook got a slightly bigger paycheck. That is what a durable win usually looks like.