Blog

Florida's Amendment 4 and the Fight Over Whether Former Felons Can Vote

Florida voters restored voting rights to most people with felony records in 2018, then a 2019 law required paying fines first. How the courts ruled.

On November 6, 2018, Florida did something unusual for a closely divided swing state: it agreed with itself. The same electorate that chose a Republican governor and a Republican senator by margins so thin they went to recounts also approved Amendment 4 to the state constitution, which restored the right to vote to most Floridians with felony convictions once they had completed their sentences. Constitutional amendments in Florida need sixty percent of the vote. Amendment 4 cleared that bar comfortably, with roughly two-thirds of voters in favour. Its campaign had been led by Desmond Meade, a man who had once stood by railroad tracks in Miami, homeless and addicted, and thought about ending his life, and who later earned a law degree while the law still barred him from voting. The amendment took effect in January 2019. Within months, the legislature had passed a law that changed what it meant, and the fight over that law would run through state and federal courts for years.

In short: Amendment 4 restored voting rights to Floridians with most felony convictions after they completed all terms of their sentences. A 2019 law, SB 7066, defined those terms to include court fines, fees and restitution, and federal appeals courts upheld it in 2020. Many people remain unsure whether they owe anything, and some who voted in good faith were later arrested.

The ban Amendment 4 replaced

Before 2019, Florida was one of a small number of states that barred people with felony convictions from voting for life, unless the governor and cabinet granted clemency. The ban dated to the nineteenth century and, like similar laws across the South, was written into state constitutions in an era when lawmakers were looking for race-neutral language that would keep Black citizens from voting.

In practice, clemency was rare and slow. Under Governor Rick Scott, the state in 2011 imposed waiting periods of at least five years after a sentence ended before a person could even apply, and the clemency board, which met only a few times a year, heard a small number of cases at each meeting. Applicants appeared in person and answered questions about their lives. A federal judge in 2018 ruled that the process gave officials unconstitutionally arbitrary power to decide who could vote, though the case did not ultimately force the state to restore rights automatically.

The result was a very large disenfranchised population. Estimates at the time of the 2018 vote put the number of Floridians barred from voting by a past felony conviction at more than a million, a disproportionate share of them Black. Florida had a larger number of people locked out of the vote this way than any other state.

What voters approved

Amendment 4 was written plainly. It said that a person disqualified from voting because of a felony conviction would have their voting rights restored upon completion of all terms of sentence, including parole or probation. People convicted of murder or a felony sexual offence were excluded and would still need clemency.

The campaign behind it, organized by the Florida Rights Restoration Coalition with Meade as its public face, was deliberately nonpartisan. It drew support from Republicans and Democrats, from evangelical churches and civil rights groups, from conservative advocates for second chances and progressive advocates for voting rights. Its message centred on redemption and forgiveness rather than on partisan advantage, and many of its volunteers were people with records themselves.

That framing is a model worth studying. The campaign did not ask voters to agree about the criminal justice system. It asked whether a person who had served their sentence deserved a voice. Roughly two-thirds of Florida voters said yes.

The 2019 law: what "all terms" means

Amendment 4 took effect on January 8, 2019, and thousands of newly eligible Floridians registered. The question that quickly arose was what "completion of all terms of sentence" meant. Prison and probation were clearly included. But Florida, like many states, imposes a range of financial obligations at sentencing: fines, court costs, fees and restitution to victims. Did those count?

The Republican-led legislature answered yes. SB 7066, which Governor Ron DeSantis signed in 2019, defined the terms of a sentence to include all financial obligations ordered by the court as part of the sentence. A person who had finished prison and probation but still owed court-ordered money remained ineligible until it was paid, waived by the court or converted to community service, with some limited exceptions.

The legislature's case for the law deserves a fair hearing. Its supporters argued that the amendment's language, "all terms of sentence," plainly included the financial parts of a sentence, which are imposed by the same judge in the same judgment. They pointed out that during the campaign, some backers of the amendment had acknowledged in court that fines and restitution could be considered part of a sentence. They argued that restitution, especially, is owed to victims, and that a sentence is not complete while a victim is still unpaid. In January 2020, the Florida Supreme Court, asked by the governor for an advisory opinion, agreed that "all terms of sentence" in the amendment included those financial obligations.

The counter-argument is equally serious. Many people leave the justice system owing hundreds or thousands of dollars in fees that have little to do with punishment or victims, charges that pay for the operation of courts and clerks' offices. For a person earning low wages, those debts can take years or decades to pay, and some debts grow through collection surcharges. Tying the vote to payment means two people with the same conviction and the same sentence can have different rights depending on their bank accounts. Opponents argued that this amounted to a wealth test for voting.

The federal court fight

Voting rights groups sued in federal court on behalf of people who had completed their sentences but could not afford to pay. Judge Robert Hinkle of the Northern District of Florida held a trial and, in May 2020, ruled that Florida could not deny the vote to people who were genuinely unable to pay. He also found that the state had no reliable way to tell many people how much they owed. Court records were scattered among dozens of county clerks' offices, some old records were incomplete, and the state had not built a system to determine who was eligible.

The state appealed. The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, sitting en banc with all its active judges, stayed Hinkle's ruling before the 2020 primary, and the Supreme Court declined to lift that stay in July 2020, over a dissent by three justices. In September 2020, the full Eleventh Circuit reversed Hinkle by a vote of six to four. The majority held that Florida had a legitimate interest in requiring people to complete their full sentences, including financial terms, and that the law did not violate the Equal Protection Clause or the Twenty-Fourth Amendment's ban on poll taxes. The dissenters argued that the state was conditioning the vote on wealth and was leaving voters with no reliable way to know whether they were eligible.

Since then, the law has stood. Private donors and nonprofit groups have raised money to pay off fines and fees for people who cannot afford them, and the Florida Rights Restoration Coalition has run programs to help people learn what they owe. That effort raised questions of its own, and it is no substitute for a system that tells people clearly whether they can vote.

Voting in good faith, then arrested

The most troubling chapter came in 2022. Governor DeSantis announced the arrests of twenty people on charges of illegally voting, through the state's new Office of Election Crimes and Security. Most of the people arrested had convictions for murder or sexual offences, which the amendment excludes. But many said they had been told, by local officials or by the state's own voter registration process, that they were eligible. Some had been issued voter registration cards. Several of the cases were later dismissed or ended without a conviction, in part because judges questioned whether the defendants had knowingly broken the law and whether the statewide prosecutor had jurisdiction.

The episode exposed the central weakness of the system. Florida registers voters, and the state is responsible for screening eligibility. When the state registers a person and later prosecutes them for voting, the burden of the state's own confusion falls on the individual. Whatever one thinks of the underlying law, a system in which people cannot reliably learn whether they may vote is unfair to them.

The wider picture

Florida's fight sits within a national shift. Over the past two decades, many states have eased or ended lifetime voting bans and restored rights after release from prison or after completion of a sentence. A few states, Maine and Vermont among them, never take the vote away at all, even during incarceration. Other states have moved in the opposite direction or added new requirements. The rules now vary enormously, and the same conviction can carry very different consequences depending on where a person lives.

There is a strong case, which we make as opinion, that voting is part of reentry rather than a reward for completing it. People who vote are invested in their communities, and civic participation is one of the signs of a person rebuilding a life. A system that ties the vote to court debts that a person may never be able to pay keeps them on the margins long after their sentence is served. And the 2018 vote showed that Floridians across the political spectrum share some version of that view.

Second chances as common ground

The story of Amendment 4 is not only one of defeat. More than a million Floridians were told, by their neighbours, that they deserved a voice. Many tens of thousands have registered and voted since. Desmond Meade, who could not vote when he began the campaign, has since voted himself. Donors from across the spectrum paid off debts for people they had never met. Prosecutors and judges in some counties have worked to waive or convert fees.

What remains is to finish the promise. That means a single, reliable way for any Floridian to learn whether they owe anything and how much, protection for those who register in good faith, and an honest debate about whether court fees should stand between a citizen and a ballot.

Fines, fees and restitution are not the same thing

Much of the public argument lumps three kinds of court debt together, and separating them clarifies where reasonable people actually disagree.

Restitution is money a court orders a defendant to pay a victim to repair a specific harm: the value of stolen property, medical bills, lost wages. It is the strongest case for treating a financial obligation as part of a sentence, because there is a person on the other end who is owed something. Even many advocates of rights restoration accept that restitution matters, while arguing that the ballot should not hinge on it when a person simply cannot pay.

Fines are punishment set by a judge, in the same way a jail term is. They are part of the sentence in the most direct sense, though they are often imposed with little inquiry into whether the defendant can afford them.

Fees and court costs are different again. They are charges, often set by statute rather than by a judge's discretion, that help pay for the courts, the clerks, public defenders, prosecution and probation supervision. A person may be billed for the cost of their own case. These charges have little to do with what the person did or whom they harmed, and they are the bulk of what many Floridians owe.

A policy that treated these three categories differently, perhaps requiring good-faith progress on restitution while setting fees aside for voting purposes, would answer the strongest version of each side's argument. Florida's law does not draw that line, and neither did the courts, which were asked only whether the state's chosen line was constitutional, not whether it was wise.

What the campaign taught organizers

The Amendment 4 campaign is studied by organizers in other states for reasons that have little to do with its legal aftermath. It built a coalition across party lines by refusing to make the question partisan. Its volunteers were, in many cases, the people the amendment would affect, and they told their own stories in churches, union halls and community centres. It talked about grace and accountability in the same breath. That approach won votes in rural counties that had supported Republican candidates on the same ballot.

The lesson is not that every issue can be framed this way. It is that some can, and that progressives lose ground when they assume a cause must be fought along party lines before trying to find the neighbours on the other side who already agree.

What you can do

  • Check the rules in your state. Our voting guide explains registration, ID and early and mail voting in every state and links to each election office, which can confirm eligibility rules for people with past convictions.
  • Ask your state legislators about fines and fees. Find them through the representatives lookup and ask whether your state ties voting rights to court debt and whether it offers a clear way to check eligibility.
  • Support reentry and legal aid groups. Organizations that help people restore their rights, resolve court debt and register are listed in our organizations directory under justice reform and legal aid.
  • Follow criminal justice reform. Our topic page on criminal justice reform gathers reporting on voting rights restoration, sentencing and reentry.

Latest on this topic