Blog
Grants Pass v. Johnson and the Punishment of Sleeping Outside
What the Supreme Court decided in Grants Pass v. Johnson in 2024, how the majority and the dissent read the Eighth Amendment, and what cities did once fines for sleeping outside were allowed.
Grants Pass is a small city in southern Oregon on the Rogue River, a place better known for river rafting and a giant caveman statue than for constitutional law. But by the time its case reached the Supreme Court, the town's ordinances against camping in public parks had become the vehicle for one of the most consequential homelessness decisions in American history. The rules themselves were ordinary: no sleeping in public places with bedding, no camping on public property. What made them famous was a lawsuit arguing that, in a town with more homeless people than shelter beds, punishing someone for sleeping outside with a blanket was punishing them for something they could not avoid. On June 28, 2024, the Court rejected that argument, six to three. Cities across the country, many of them run by Democrats, had been waiting for the answer.
In short: In City of Grants Pass v. Johnson, the Supreme Court ruled in 2024 that enforcing general laws against camping on public property does not violate the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment, even when shelter is unavailable. The ruling removed a legal limit that had bound western cities for years and left the question of how to respond to homelessness to elected officials.
The rule the Court overturned
To understand the case, start in Boise, Idaho. In 2018, the federal appeals court for the Ninth Circuit, which covers much of the West, ruled in Martin v. City of Boise that a city could not prosecute homeless people for sleeping outside on public property when they had no access to shelter. The court reasoned that sleeping is an unavoidable consequence of being human, and that punishing someone for doing it when they have nowhere else to go amounts to punishing them for their status of being homeless.
The Ninth Circuit drew on a 1962 Supreme Court case, Robinson v. California, which held that a state could not make it a crime simply to be addicted to narcotics. Robinson stood for the idea that the Eighth Amendment forbids punishing a status rather than an act. A later case, Powell v. Texas in 1968, complicated that line: a divided Court upheld a conviction for public drunkenness, distinguishing the act of being drunk in public from the status of being an alcoholic.
Martin applied Robinson to homelessness. In Grants Pass, the Ninth Circuit extended Martin, allowing a class action on behalf of the town's homeless residents and limiting civil fines and park exclusion orders. The town, joined by many western cities and states, asked the Supreme Court to step in.
The town, the plaintiffs and the numbers
The named plaintiffs included Gloria Johnson, a homeless woman in Grants Pass, who argued that she and others like her had nowhere else to sleep. The town's shelter capacity was limited, and its main shelter operated under religious rules that some homeless residents could not or would not follow.
The ordinances worked through escalating penalties. A person found sleeping in a park with bedding could be fined. Repeated violations could lead to an order excluding the person from parks. Violating that order could be prosecuted as criminal trespass, which carries the possibility of jail. The town argued that these were general rules about the use of public property, applied to everyone; the plaintiffs argued that in practice they applied only to people with nowhere else to go.
What the majority held
Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote the majority opinion, joined by the Chief Justice and Justices Thomas, Alito, Kavanaugh and Barrett.
The majority made two central moves. First, it read the Eighth Amendment's Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause as concerned with the method or kind of punishment a government imposes after conviction, not with what conduct can be criminalized. Fines and short jail terms, the opinion said, are not cruel and unusual in the sense the clause addresses.
Second, it distinguished Robinson. The Grants Pass laws, the majority said, do not punish the status of being homeless. They punish the act of camping on public property, and that act is prohibited for everyone, whether a homeless person or a backpacker or a student protester. A law that applies to conduct, regardless of the actor's status, falls outside Robinson's rule.
The majority also stressed practical concerns. It said the Martin framework had left cities confused about what counted as available shelter, what counted as camping and how much enforcement was permitted. It noted that homelessness is a complex problem with many causes, including addiction, mental illness and housing costs, and that federal judges applying the Eighth Amendment are poorly placed to manage it. Those choices, the majority said, belong to the people and their elected representatives.
What the dissent argued
Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissented, joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson. She read the plain effect of the ordinances very differently.
The dissent argued that the laws, as Grants Pass designed and enforced them, effectively punished people for being homeless in a town without enough shelter. Sleeping, the dissent said, is a biological necessity, and a person without a home must sleep somewhere. A law that makes it a crime to sleep anywhere public, with even a blanket, when there is nowhere private to go, leaves the person no lawful option. That, in the dissent's view, is exactly the status-based punishment Robinson forbids.
The dissent also pointed to the town's own record, which it argued showed an intent to drive homeless people out of Grants Pass rather than to regulate conduct neutrally. And it worried about the practical result: fines that homeless people cannot pay, debts that grow, warrants and jail stays that make it harder to get a job or housing.
Both opinions are worth reading in full, and the reader should come away seeing that the dispute is not only about compassion. It is about what kind of question the Constitution answers. The majority thought the Eighth Amendment limits how government punishes, not what it punishes. The dissent thought that, at the extreme, punishing an unavoidable bodily act is punishing who you are.
The strongest case for the city's side
Many progressives reacted to the ruling with dismay, and I share that reaction. But it is important to understand why so many officials, including Democratic governors and mayors, wanted the Court to overturn Martin.
Big encampments create real problems. Fires. Public health dangers, including disease outbreaks. Crime, including violence against homeless people themselves, who are often the victims. Blocked sidewalks that make it hard for people using wheelchairs. Parks that families stop using. City officials said that Martin, and the wider Ninth Circuit rulings that followed it, made it hard to manage encampments even when they offered shelter, because the line between permitted and forbidden enforcement was unclear and litigation was constant. California's governor, Gavin Newsom, filed a brief urging the Court to clarify that cities could enforce camping rules, while asking it to stop short of permitting the criminalization of homelessness itself.
Their strongest point is that tolerating encampments indefinitely is not compassionate either. People die in them, from overdoses, exposure and violence. A city that does nothing is choosing something too.
The answer, I think, is that the ruling gives cities a tool without giving them the thing the tool needs. Enforcement can clear a park. It cannot produce an apartment. If a city enforces camping bans without enough housing and shelter to offer, people move to the next park, the next block, the riverbank, the woods outside town. The problem relocates. Fines that cannot be paid become warrants. Jail stays cost the public more than many forms of supportive housing would. The ruling is about what the Constitution permits. It says nothing about whether the policy works.
What cities did next
The response came quickly. Within weeks, Newsom issued an executive order directing state agencies to clear encampments on state property and urging local governments to do the same, with notice to residents and offers of services. San Francisco began more aggressive sweeps. Other cities, in California and beyond, adopted or toughened camping bans, some with new jail penalties. A few cities took the opposite path and kept a policy of not enforcing camping bans unless shelter was available.
At the federal level, the national approach also shifted. In 2025, the Trump administration issued an executive order that pushed federal agencies away from the Housing First approach that had guided homelessness policy under presidents of both parties, and toward treatment requirements and civil commitment for people with serious mental illness or addiction.
Meanwhile, the national count of homeless people rose. The government's point-in-time count in January 2024, conducted before the ruling, found more than 770,000 people homeless on a single night, the highest number recorded since the count began, driven by high rents, the end of pandemic aid and a rise in migrants arriving in some cities.
Fines that cannot be paid
The ruling treated fines and short jail stays as ordinary punishments, and in the abstract they are. A parking ticket is a fine. But it helps to follow what a fine does in the life of someone with no income and no address.
The citation arrives. The person cannot pay it. Unpaid, it may grow with fees, and after enough time it can lead to a warrant or a court date. Without a mailing address, the person may never receive notice of the court date, misses it, and now faces a failure-to-appear charge. A night or a week in jail follows. In jail, the person may lose the tent and belongings left behind, and the spot in line for a housing program. When released, the person returns to the street with a record that makes renting an apartment or landing a job harder than before.
None of that requires bad faith by any police officer or judge. It is how an enforcement system built for people with homes behaves when applied to people without them. Each step costs the public money: police time, court time, jail beds that cost far more per night than a motel room. And at the end, the person is in the same situation as before, sleeping outside, only with more obstacles to getting inside.
Some cities that adopted camping bans after the ruling paired them with diversion programs, so that a citation leads to an offer of shelter or services rather than a court date. That design is worth watching. It treats enforcement as a way to make contact with someone who needs help, rather than as an end in itself. Whether it works depends, again, on whether there is a bed or an apartment at the other end of the offer.
The question the ruling leaves for voters
The Court did not say that cities must punish people for sleeping outside. It said they may. That shifts the debate from courtrooms to city councils and state legislatures, where it may belong, but it also raises the stakes of local elections.
Some states have their own laws. Oregon, for instance, had already passed a law requiring cities' camping rules to be objectively reasonable for homeless people, which shapes how its towns can respond regardless of the federal ruling. State constitutions may also be read to provide more protection than the federal one. Those questions will play out in state courts and statehouses for years.
The deeper question is what kind of response a city chooses. The research and experience of many places point toward housing as the thing that actually reduces homelessness: permanent supportive housing for people with disabilities and addictions, rapid rehousing for people who simply fell behind, and, most of all, more housing overall so that rents stop pricing people onto the street. Houston, for example, reduced its homeless population by more than half over about a decade by coordinating agencies and moving people directly into housing. That kind of approach is slower and less visible than a sweep, but it is the one that empties encampments for good.
What you can do
- Learn what your city is doing. After the ruling, many councils passed or revised camping laws, sometimes quickly. Find out whether yours did, and whether it comes with shelter and housing to offer. The homelessness topic page gathers current reporting on these local fights.
- Show up when the council votes. Camping ordinances are local laws, decided at public meetings. A handful of residents who testify about housing-first results, the cost of jail and what the city plans to offer can change a council member's mind.
- Support the people doing outreach. Groups that provide shelter, legal aid and services to homeless residents often need volunteers and donations. The organizations directory lists housing, legal aid and food bank organizations by state.
- Contact your state legislators. Several states are considering laws on how cities can enforce camping bans and on funding for supportive housing. The representatives lookup gives you their contact information.
- Read the opinions yourself. The court watch page follows the Supreme Court's opinions this term with the Court's own summaries; cases on criminal law and city power often matter as much locally as nationally.
The Court has settled what the federal Constitution allows. It has not settled what a decent city does. That part is up to the people who live there.